Re: Affiliation disclosure in security WGs

  *
I agree we should focus on technical merit. The problem is that participants making technical arguments are being moderated, while participants posting 'I support publication' are counted toward consensus and those attacking the people making technical arguments face no consequences. When the system punishes argument and rewards assertion, "focus on the technical perspective" is empty advice.

As a long-time participant in the TLS working group, which I believe Andrew is referring to, I will just say that his view of things is not widely shared.