Re: Agenda Krb-WG Session ietf 83

Hi Simon and Sam,

Thanks for this first feedback.

Coming to the questions of Simon: for question (a) I think that you
need a reply from Kerberos implementors. For question (b) I can tell
you that we implemented the proposed approach using the Kerberos open
source and we tested the implementation in a wireless mesh networks.

Hope that we can have further discussion from the WG in order to
decide on the possibility of presenting this draft.

Kind regards,
Hassnaa

On 2/9/12, Simon Josefsson <[email protected]> wrote:
> Sam Hartman <[email protected]> writes:
>
>>     Hasnaa> If there would be a session, I would like to know the
>>     Hasnaa> possibility of having a slot for presenting the draft
>>
>>     Hasnaa> (Authentication in Wireless Mesh Networks Through Kerberos
>>     Hasnaa> Tickets <draft-moustafa-krb-wg-mesh-nw-02> ).
>>
>>
>> We've not seen a lot of interest in this draft from parties other than
>> the authors.  I think we'd need to see significant interest from other
>> parties before presenting this draft again would make sense.
>>
>> I'd like to hear comments from other WG participants who would like to
>> spend time on this topic.
>
> I'm somewhat confused after browsing the document.  It is targeted as an
> informational document, it contains a problem statement, and then a
> "solution proposal extending the Kerberos authentication model".
>
> a) Are there any changes required for any Kerberos implementer to
> support this document?
>
> b) Is the "solution proposal" more than just a proposal, i.e., is it
> something that can be implemented at all?
>
> If the answer to a) and b) is yes, I believe it would be useful to
> review the document in this WG.
>
> The document appears to allocate a new KDCOptions flag.  I cannot find
> any registration policy for the KDCOption namespace in RFC 4120.  If
> this document moves forward, I think that problem needs to be resolved
> first.
>
> /Simon
>
_______________________________________________
ietf-krb-wg mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.anl.gov/mailman/listinfo/ietf-krb-wg