G9/G10 (Was: Coverage matrix..)

At 06:23 PM 2001-11-21, Ed Reed wrote:
>For better or worse, here is my take on how the current Model document addresses the current Requirements document requirements.
>
>I've highlighted comments for requirements not addressed or explicitly broken, in a bold type font.

I'll comment only on the two which might be viewed as suggesting
changes to the requirements I-D.

G9.1 N/A 

I concur.


G10.  Note that this REQUIRES that changes to RootDSE information be
maintained OUTSIDE of LDUP, either directly via Management Operations,
or as side effects of those Management Operations.

Well, I think it's a matter of properly specify the relationship
between DSA-specific information in the root DSE and replication
policy/state information held elsewhere in non-DSA specific
attributes.

For example, namingContexts is maintained on a DSA-specific basis
but is derived from non-DSA-specific information held elsewhere
in the DIT.  I would think that any replication-specific attribute
added to the root DSE would be DSA-specific but, as needed,
derived from non-DSA-specific information held elsewhere in the
DIT.

I see the G10 as being a very appropriate requirement.  It requires
LDUP not change the meaning of DSA specific.

Kurt