LCUP Eventual Convergence, one possible approach
"Kurt D. Zeilenga" <[email protected]> Thu, 31 Oct 2002 10:11:32 -0800
| Newsgroups | gmane.ietf.ldup |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
As noted during the LCUP I-D's WG Last Call, there are some significant eventual convergence issues with the current LCUP approach. Jong and I have been experimenting with LCUP and exploring different approaches to provide eventual convergence. We believe that "running code" is necessary to ensure we standardize a sound approach. We think we may have workable approach to offer. However, the approach is somewhat experimental. We have not yet convinced ourselves that it "works" (e.g., we haven't coded it yet). A number of complex issues still need to be sorted out. draft-zeilenga-ldup-sync-00.txt describes the basic approach we are pursuing. Your comments are welcomed. Our I-D is not intended to compete with the LCUP I-D. It is provided to further discussions of the LCUP eventual convergence issues. It should be noted that there are likely other viable approaches to providing eventual convergence. Our I-D offers one possible approach. It is our hope that that the LDUP WG can quickly reach consensus on approach and then have the LCUP authors run with it. (We are willing to aid the authors in anyway we can.) To this end, we ask that sufficient time be allocated at IETF#55 to discuss LCUP eventual convergence issues, possible approaches, and next steps. As these issues are quite complex, it may advantageous to have some informal discussions prior to the LDUP session (by telechat if necessary). Kurt & Jong