Re: Last Call: draft-ietf-magma-mgmd-mib(MulticastGroup Membership Discovery MIB) to Proposed Standard

Looks like there was a misunderstanding on my part r.e. the 
InetAddressType refinement. The refinement only applies to the 
InetAddress objects, InetAddressType should be unmodified, apologies for 
that. I'll issue an update, however AFAIK the other comments still apply.

Thanks,
Julian

Wijnen, Bert (Bert) wrote:

>Based on the errors/warnings I get from both SMICNG and SMILINT, I
>wonder how 
>how an IETF Last Call can go out for a MIB module in this shape.
>
>I did not look at any MIB details yet.
>
>I get this from SMICng:
>
>C:\bwijnen\smicng\work>smicng mgmd.inc
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (90,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (246,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (487,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (590,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (644,27) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>TimeTicks
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (751,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (835,38) A SIZE or range clause may not be used with
>ENUM
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (797,5) Item "mgmdRouterInterfaceIfIndex" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry" is not a column for row
>"mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (798,5) Item "mgmdRouterCacheAddressType" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry" is not a column for row
>"mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (799,5) Item "mgmdRouterCacheAddress" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry" is not a column for row
>"mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (910,5) Item "mgmdRouterCacheAddressType" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterSrcListEntry" is not a column for row "
>mgmdRouterSrcListEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (911,5) Item "mgmdRouterCacheAddress" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterSrcListEntry" is not a column for row "mgmd
>RouterSrcListEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (912,5) Item "mgmdRouterCacheIfIndex" in sequence
>"MgmdRouterSrcListEntry" is not a column for row "mgmd
>RouterSrcListEntry"
>E: f(mgmd.mi2), (784,1) Row "mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry" must have leaf
>objects defined under it
>W: f(mgmd.mi2), (791,18) Row "mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry" does not have
>a consistent indexing scheme - cannot specify a n index item from
>additional "base row" mgmdRouterInterfaceEntry, since can have only one
>"base row" which is mgmdRouter CacheEntry
>
>*** 14 errors and 1 warning in parsing
>
>And I get this from smilint:
>
>C:\bwijnen\smicng\work>smilint -m -l 6 -s ./MGMD-STD-MIB
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:39: [3] {revision-missing} revision for last update is
>missing
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:90: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:100: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdHostInterfaceQuerierType' in sequence and object type defi nition
>do not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:246: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:256: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdRouterInterfaceQuerierType' in sequence and object type de finition
>do not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:487: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:494: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdHostCacheAddressType' in sequence and object type definiti on do
>not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:590: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:597: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdRouterCacheAddressType' in sequence and object type defini tion do
>not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:644: [2] {subtype-illegal} subtyping not allowed
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:751: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:756: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdInverseHostCacheAddressType' in sequence and object type d
>efinition do not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:798: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdRouterCacheAddressType' in sequence and object type defini tion do
>not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:835: [2] {size-illegal} illegal size restriction for
>non-octet-string parent type `InetAddressType'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:842: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdHostSrcListAddressType' in sequence and object type defini tion do
>not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:910: [2] {sequence-type-mismatch} type of
>`mgmdRouterCacheAddressType' in sequence and object type defini tion do
>not match
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:796: [3] {sequence-no-column} SEQUENCE element #1
>`mgmdRouterInterfaceIfIndex' is not a child node under
>`mgmdRouterInverseCacheEntry'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:784: [5] {index-element-not-accessible} warning: exactly
>one index element of row `mgmdRouterInverseCache Entry' must be
>accessible
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:909: [3] {sequence-no-column} SEQUENCE element #1
>`mgmdRouterCacheAddressType' is not a child node under
>`mgmdRouterSrcListEntry'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:909: [3] {sequence-no-column} SEQUENCE element #2
>`mgmdRouterCacheAddress' is not a child node under `mgm
>dRouterSrcListEntry'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:909: [3] {sequence-no-column} SEQUENCE element #3
>`mgmdRouterCacheIfIndex' is not a child node under `mgm
>dRouterSrcListEntry'
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:102: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:258: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:496: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:524: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:599: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:620: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:758: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:844: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:862: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
>`InetAdressType' object
>./MGMD-STD-MIB:917: [5] {inetaddress-inetaddresstype} warning:
>`InetAddress' object should have an accompanied preceding
> `InetAdressType' object	
>Bert Wijnen  
>
>  
>
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: The IESG [mailto:[email protected]]
>>Sent: Thursday, August 30, 2007 5:24 PM
>>To: IETF-Announce
>>Cc: [email protected]
>>Subject: Last Call: draft-ietf-magma-mgmd-mib (Multicast Group 
>>Membership Discovery MIB) to Proposed Standard
>>
>>The IESG has received a request from the Multicast & Anycast Group 
>>Membership WG (magma) to consider the following document:
>>
>>- 'Multicast Group Membership Discovery MIB '
>>   <draft-ietf-magma-mgmd-mib-10.txt> as a Proposed Standard
>>
>>The IESG plans to make a decision in the next few weeks, and solicits 
>>final comments on this action.  Please send substantive comments to 
>>the [email protected] mailing lists by 2007-09-13. Exceptionally, comments
>>    
>>
>
>  
>
>>may be sent to [email protected] instead. In either case, please retain 
>>the beginning of the Subject line to allow automated sorting.
>>
>>The file can be obtained via
>>http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-magma-mgmd-mib-10.txt
>>
>>
>>IESG discussion can be tracked via
>>https://datatracker.ietf.org/public/pidtracker.cgi?command=vie
>>w_id&dTag=
>>10603&rfc_flag=0
>>    
>>


_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf