IESG review of draft-ietf-dmm-requirements

All,
     The IESG discussed the requirements draft on its call yesterday.
There are a few items that need to be addressed in the document and a
larger, more educational, step that needs to be done prior to
publication.  There are two concrete changes needed in the document at
this time.  Barry Leiba raised the issue about the references to 3753,
5213, and 6275 should be normative.  Alia Atlas has asked that there be
some description of the applicability or deployment considerations
driving these requirements.  I think a good way to address this would be
to describe a common deployment model in use today and point out where
the requirements would lead to changes.  It may be useful to have
someone engage Alia on this topic.

      Another point raised, by Benoit Claise, is the OAM issue with
these requirements.  Benoit would either like to see OAM issues
discussed in the requirements document or in the new charter.  I think
that is a valid concern that the WG needs to discuss, specifically where
that need should be documented. As with the above, someone from DMM
should chat with Benoit if there are questions on what he would like to see.

     There are also a few good Comments raised by other ADs that should
be addressed.  Those can be seen on the document's ballot page:

https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-dmm-requirements/ballot/

     The last issue raised, by Ted Lemon, is the architectural impact of
the mobility work.  He ties it to this document since he is fearful that
these requirements will lead to a solution that impacts the overall
Internet architecture.  To that end, I suggested that he invite several
DMM participants (I suggested the chairs) to participate in an upcoming
informal IESG call to discuss.  I suspect that Ted will hold this
document until that conversation occurs.

     Let me know if anyone has any questions on these points.

Regards,
Brian (your slightly frazzled AD)

_______________________________________________
dmm mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmm

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.20 (Darwin)
Comment: GPGTools - https://gpgtools.org

iQEcBAEBCgAGBQJTNX8gAAoJEBOZRqCi7goqShMH/iHDvP1P/kSkHnHAz3welhAP
BRikpcNfBlT/QDjEc4DMcuYraJ41daAm6DsR1nkkHd0429XgN6sWtHUmgErWUrvm
CzFv2KuX3ZGjwcYeQzYI6bR5iwK+HiV1a6IDOJi3quROcdEOrTdLhc+8nb6bAg7y
PX7u9fd2LMaJOqtJavzqoBlR5et0VGdzM0ggbLmk2klZ1UVAGY7vZ8zq1fexxa7B
sfULNiOpozPkQJeX7vgoGzB7SAREPgOHmXSfULZoW9ZptpTCM967dmYcSpd9f1xa
u62/NCELL0fZ6pFBachk7mla9Pfh9Lu169lrj3zmQI5rjdg59ELomzUJFoi4cxA=
=4FNb
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----