Re: WGLC on draft-ietf-nsis-nslp-auth-02.txt

Hi Xiaoming,

Am 22.06.2010 13:21, schrieb Xiaoming Fu:
> Reads good to me. One comment:
> 
>    AB=00 ("Mandatory"): If the object is not understood, the entire
>    message containing it MUST be rejected, and an error message sent
>    back (usually of class/code "Protocol Error/Unknown object present").
> 
> "Protocol Error/Unknown object present" --> "Protocol Error/Object Type
> Error (subcode Unrecognised Object)"?

The latest qos nslp draft says:

   * 0x07 - Unknown object present: an object of an unknown type was
   present in the message.

The latest natfw draft says:
   o  AB=00 ("Mandatory"): If the object is not understood, the entire
      message containing it MUST be rejected with an error RESPONSE of
      class 'Protocol error' (0x3) with response code 'Unknown object
      present' (0x06).

So why do you think that this must be changed?

Regards,
 Roland