Re: Draft charter for L2VPN

Alex,

> >> >  The effort will produce a small number of approaches that are based
> >> >  on collections of individual technologies. The goal is to foster 
> >> >  interoperability among implementations of a specific approach. 
> >> >  Standardization of specific approaches will be gauged on (I)SP support. 
> >> 
> >> Please state why you believe this should be in the charter and what
> >> exactly your proposed text would mean.
> 
> > This should be in the charter for exactly the same reason(s) it is
> > in the current PPVPN charter. It means exactly the same as it
> > means in the current PPVPN charter.
> 
> Many people on this list (including me) were not intimately involved
> in writing of the PPVPN WG charter. Therefore, I believe you should
> explain your reasoning (i.e. why you think the text is useful, how,
> and what it really means) before we can consider putting this phrase
> in the proposed charter.

I would suggest that the folks who wrote the PPVPN WG charter (the IESG 
ADs + the WG chairs) should do this. 

Yakov.