Review comments from Basavaraj Patel on CTP
"James Kempf" <[email protected]> Tue, 21 Oct 2003 14:42:37 -0700
| Newsgroups | gmane.ietf.seamoby |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <02cd01c3981c$42838e50$0a6015ac@dclkempt40> |
Forwarding.
jak
------------------------------------
My comments are editorial only:
Editorial:
1. Can the problem description text in the Introduction be a
subsection? The current Into section begins with a reference to a
problem statement described in RFC3374.
Nit: The open quote "Problem... in Section 1 is not terminated.
2. s/This section provides a protocol overview/This section provides the
CT protocol overview.
3. Section 2: (References)
"In response to a CT-Activate Request message or to the CT trigger, pAR
predictively transmits a Context Transfer Data (CTD) message that
contains feature contexts. This message, described in Section
2.4.2"
Incorrect reference.
"In the second scenario, pAR receives a Context Transfer Request (CT
Request) described in Section 2.4.5, message from nAR."
Incorrect reference; Should be 2.4.6
Nit: Check all references
4. Section 2:
"[1].* contexts, pAR verifies authorization token before transmitting
the [2]algorithm [3] When context transfer takes place without the
nAR requesting it (scenario one above), nAR requires MN to present
its authorization token"
I could not make out what this statement says. I am not even sure
if the authors can understand it.
5. Section 2:
Can you create subsections for scenarios 1 and 2? Would make it
easier to reference.
6. s/Additially/Additionally
7. Section 2.3
a. Would be good to describe each field separately. Goes for all
subsequent sections where message formats are described.
CXT Type -
Length -
P bit -
b. "When the presence vector is in use, the Presentation Vector is
interpreted.."
What is this Presentation vector? (Typo)
c. Last paragraph has % chars
8. Sec 2.4.1
"If an acknowledgement for this message is needed, the MN sets the
A flag to 1, "
Missing "A" flag in CTAR.
9. Sec 2.4.2
Describe the fields.
10. Is there a need for specifying the status codes used in CTDR and
CTAA?