Re: I-D Action: draft-ietf-simple-chat-14.txt

Hi, Miguel,

I just read it and what I mentioned has been addressed as discussed :-)

A couple of minor things, though:

In section 4: "All messages in the chat room use the 'Message/CPIM' wrapper content
   type [RFC3862]..."

and a bit later, in section 5: "The conference focus of a chat room MUST include support for a	
   Message/CPIM [RFC3862] top-level wrapper for the MSRP messages by	 	   Message/CPIM [RFC3862]"

I see that support for CPIM is a MUST for the Focus, but the behavior of the Focus if an endpoint doesn't support it could be unclear. Should CPIM be a MUST also for endpoints joining a chat room? IMHO it should.

In section 7.1: "The user can select a different nickname and retry
   another NICKNAME request. nickname is not allocated to this user"."

There seems to be an editing mistake after the dot.


Regards,

--
Saúl Ibarra Corretgé
AG Projects