[urn] Re: Informal URN Namespace Registration Request for Tr ivore Corp.

Thank you Lars, Dale, and others!

What  you pointed out below is exactly our current state with Trivore ID product.
I am very frank with you, it is currently a mess. I personally do not like the current state.
We have scopes and claims with https prefix, and we have plain strings.
Those current url scopes and claims are already internally deprecated, and will be changed to urn based on this registration "urn:trviore".
This registration is part of that.

We are modifying all those to what is according to new standard, showing up those urn scopes and claims in the documentation in the future releases. Trivore ID is a 10 year old product already and being actively use by millions of people.
Refactoring is currently being done.

I hope this clarified the current state.

my best, Kari

________________________________
From: Lars G. Svensson <[email protected]>
Sent: 23 January 2026 14:02
To: Kari Mattsson (Trivore) <[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected] <[email protected]>; URN-admin <[email protected]>
Subject: AW: [urn] Re: Informal URN Namespace Registration Request for Trivore Corp.

Dear Kari,

Apologies for the delay with our review.

Apart from the documentation issue addressed by Dale (below), we approve of the registration request.

Best,

Stephanie and Lars

-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: Dale R. Worley [mailto:[email protected]]
Gesendet: Mittwoch, 14. Januar 2026 05:14
An: Kari Mattsson (Trivore) <[email protected]>
Cc: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]
Betreff: [urn] Re: Informal URN Namespace Registration Request for Trivore Corp.

The new registration says:

    The Namespace Specific String (NSS) is defined as a hierarchical
    sequence of segments:
    <NSS> = <segment> 1*(":" <segment>)

    Where:
    <segment> consists of ASCII letters, digits, and the characters “-”,
    “_”, and “.”, and the NSS must contain at least one colon (implying
    at least two segments).

> On exact URNs for scopes and claims, yes your correction is the right
>     one, and it is important on the web page to document this clearly:
>     urn:trivore:id:scope:<scope-name>
>     urn:trivore:id:claim:<claim-name>

Looking at https://id.trivore.com/apidoc/oidc, it doesn't seem on first reading to document the URN formats clearly; it gives a list of "Supported scopes" and "Supported claims" but does not specify how these are used to form URNs.

Also the following scopes and claims are listed that do not conform to the specified syntax, in that they contain "/".  They also contain ":"
in a way which is correct according to the syntax but seems to not have the intended semantics:  according to the syntax specification the ":"
separates segments (the first one being "http", the second one starts with "//") rather than being an internal part of the scope/claim name (which is suggested by the web page).

    Scopes

    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/accesscontrol
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/accesscontrol.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/accessrights
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/accessrights.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/address.update
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisation.grant.rights
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisation.grant.rights.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations.sources
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations.sources.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations.types
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/authorisations.types.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.product.suppliers.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.product.suppliers.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.sales.products.query
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.wallet.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.wallet.transfer
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/commerce.wallet.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/consent
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/consent.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/contract.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/contract.sign
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/contract.terminate
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/contract.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/datastorage
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/datastorage.admin
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/datastorage.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/email.update
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/email.verify
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/filestorage
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/filestorage.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/groups
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/groups.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/legalinfo.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/mfa
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/mgmt.api.client
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/mgmt.api.client.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/mydata.download
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/mydata.request
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/namespace
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/namespace.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/other.app.access
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/other.app.access.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/password
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/paycards
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/paycards.number
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/paycards.number.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/paycards.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/phone.update
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.catalog.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.catalog.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.pricingplan.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.pricingplan.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.product.read
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/products.product.write
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/profile
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/profile.update
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/sms.verify
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/sso.consume
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/studentinfo.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/user.custom.fields
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/user.custom.fields.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/user.invite
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/user.tokens
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/user.tokens.readonly
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/users
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/scope/users.readonly

    Claims

    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/active_external_permissions
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/consents
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/custom_fields
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/domicile_classes
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/dynamic_custom_fields
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/group_ids
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/groupmembership
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/groups
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/legal_locality
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/legal_names
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/locality
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/minor
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/namespace
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/personal_id_code
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/screen_name
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/strong_identification
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/student
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/tags
    https://oneportal.trivore.com/claims/user_namespace

Dale

_______________________________________________
urn mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]