Re: Niggles in usepro-draft-11

Ho Thorfinn,

>>>>       Accordingly, news servers SHOULD
>>>>       apply to a Supersedes header field the same authentication and
>>>>       authorization checks as they would apply to cancel control
>>>>       messages.
>>
>> Does "the same authentication and authorization checks as they would
>> apply" versus "whatever authentication and authorization checks they  would apply" feel different in meaning to you?
>
> "the same checks" does definitely have a small difference in  implication to "whatever checks".  "the same checks" has a slightly 
> stronger implication that there is at least one check.  It's not a  hugely stronger implication, no.  And it is just in 
> implication,  rather than in explicit meaning.

Why not say "the same authentication and authorization checks, if any,
as they would apply"?

-- 
Julien ÉLIE

« La vie ne vaut rien. Mais rien ne vaut la vie. » (André Malraux)