Re: Moving exc-c14n forward: your response is needed!
Aleksey Sanin <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.ietf.xmldsig |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
Hi, Joseph,
My C14N and ExcC14N implementations included in LibXML passed all Gregor's
examples. I have some problems with Merlin's signature test but I think
it's a mistake
in the test (see bellow). Also I have few comments to Gregor's examples
Aleksey.
Issues:
--------------------------------------
1) There are extra space in the "Result EC14N" (line 34) in the
iaikTests.example3.xml file.
I believe it's copy/paste problem :)
2) In all iaikTests.example*.xml files there are extra spaces at the end
of all results
(after </Parent>). I assume that there are no more characters after
</Parent>.
3) (Merlin's "signature" test") The Merlin's c14n-0.txt file is
different from the
result in iaikTests.example1.xml. From my point of view the last is correct:
c14n-0.txt
------------------------------
<Parent xml:foo="bar" xml:fool="barbar" xml:lang="en" xml:space="default">
<GrandChild xml:foo="barbarossa" xml:lang="ge"
xml:space="preserve"></GrandChild>
</Parent>
iaikTests.example1.xml
-------------------------------
<!-- Result C14N
<Parent xml:foo="bar" xml:fool="barbar" xml:lang="en" xml:space="default">
<GrandChild xml:foo="barbarossa" xml:fool="barbar" xml:lang="ge"
xml:space="preserve"></GrandChild>
</Parent>
-->