Re: resolution of LL52 LL54 LL55 LL56 LL57 LL58 LL59 LL60 LL61 LL62 LL64 LL65 LL66 LL67 LL68 LL69

The resolutions which I included in this message are my reading of the
discussion in the preceeding last call periods.  If you believe that I
have misread the consensus, please bring this up on the working group
mailing list.  I remind participants that a very high degree of agreement
is needed to make a change at this late in the process.

I will not be able to respond to the ensuing discussion until Monday 31
May.

Best regards,

Erik Guttman
ZEROCONF WG Chair

 On Tue, 25 May 2004, Erik Guttman wrote:

>
> -----  ----------  -------------------------------
>
> Issue Type Title                                              Recommend
> ----- ---- -------------------------------------------------- ---------
> LL52   t    Text surrounding RFC 2119 clause is poor           Accept
> LL53   e    Forward references requested                       Open
> LL54   e    Consistent terminology for out of scope            Accept
> LL55   e    'Prevent' is too strong                            Accept
> LL56   t    Contradictory text?                                Reject
> LL57   e    Straightforward editorial fixes                    Accept
> LL58   t    Duplicate inconsistent routable address            Accept
>              definition
> LL59   e    Wireless comment not needed                        Accept
> LL60   e    Forward reference style                            Reject
> LL61   t    Remove random wait                                 Accept
> LL62   t    Do not space probes randomly                       Reject
> LL63   e    Text should be more explicit                       Open
> LL64   e    Simplify some text                                 Accept
> LL65   t    need a requirement for multihomed hosts            Reject
> LL66   t    Additional statistical example                     Reject
> LL67   t    Fix clause which forbids routable to LL commun-    Accept
>              ication
> LL68   e    Stress constants are not user configurable         Reject
> LL69   e    Move constants to beginning of doc                 Reject
> LL70   t    DNAv4 normative or informative?                    Open