Bug#1087993: apt: Unexpected symbol "|" appeared in upgrade confirmation prompts

Kamil Ignacak <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.linux.debian.apt.devel
Message-ID <ea63958e-8be5-444b-9a47-0513ec678e28__44624.7690751747$1746354813$gmane$org@wp.pl>
Hi!

> When apt is printing Suggested Packages section, some entries include an
> unexpected "|" symbol. This could be due to some mishandling of the
> Suggests: field contents.
[...]
> Unfortunately reproducing the bug is not that easy as it may require a
> certain package upgrade combination.

Reproduction may require certain package upgrade combination, and
specific terminal sizes. I managed to reproduce a similar behaviour
in my X terminal emulator. I hope that text in this mail won't be
wrapped...



A. Info about apt/OS

acerion@debian:~$ apt --version
apt 3.0.1 (amd64)
acerion@debian:~$ grep CODENAME /etc/os-release
VERSION_CODENAME=trixie



B. scenario with terminal size #1, where '|' characters are showing
"alternatives" in suggested packages' list in unambiguous way.

acerion@debian:~$ stty size
32 146
acerion@debian:~$ sudo apt install ant
Installing:
   ant

Installing dependencies:
   ant-optional          default-jre-headless  libavahi-client3      libavahi-common3  libnspr4  libpcsclite1
   ca-certificates-java  java-common           libavahi-common-data  libcups2t64       libnss3   openjdk-21-jre-headless

Suggested packages:
   ant-doc          junit               libcommons-logging-java  liblog4j1.2-java                 default-jre           fonts-ipafont-mincho
   default-jdk      junit4              libcommons-net-java      liboro-java                      cups-common           fonts-wqy-microhei
   | java-compiler  jython              libmail-java             libregexp-java                   pcscd                 | fonts-wqy-zenhei
   | java-sdk       libactivation-java  libjaxp1.3-java          libxalan2-java                   libnss-mdns           fonts-indic
   antlr            libbcel-java        libjdepend-java          libxml-commons-resolver1.1-java  fonts-dejavu-extra
   javacc           libbsf-java         libjsch-java             libxz-java                       fonts-ipafont-gothic

Summary:
   Upgrading: 0, Installing: 13, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 15
   Download size: 44.9 MB / 46.4 MB
   Space needed: 213 MB / 2,152 MB available

Continue? [Y/n]

In this case it's easy to recognize that fonts-wqy-zenhei is an
alternative to fonts-wqy-microhei because both packages are in a single
column. Alternative of package X is shown directly under X.




C. scenario with terminal size #2, where usage of '|' character may
lead to confusion.

acerion@debian:~$ stty size
40 190
acerion@debian:~$ sudo apt install ant
Installing:
   ant

Installing dependencies:
   ant-optional          default-jre-headless  libavahi-client3      libavahi-common3  libnspr4  libpcsclite1
   ca-certificates-java  java-common           libavahi-common-data  libcups2t64       libnss3   openjdk-21-jre-headless

Suggested packages:
   ant-doc          antlr   jython              libcommons-logging-java  libjdepend-java   libregexp-java                   default-jre  fonts-dejavu-extra    | fonts-wqy-zenhei
   default-jdk      javacc  libactivation-java  libcommons-net-java      libjsch-java      libxalan2-java                   cups-common  fonts-ipafont-gothic  fonts-indic
   | java-compiler  junit   libbcel-java        libmail-java             liblog4j1.2-java  libxml-commons-resolver1.1-java  pcscd        fonts-ipafont-mincho
   | java-sdk       junit4  libbsf-java         libjaxp1.3-java          liboro-java       libxz-java                       libnss-mdns  fonts-wqy-microhei

Summary:
   Upgrading: 0, Installing: 13, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 15
   Download size: 44.9 MB / 46.4 MB
   Space needed: 213 MB / 2,152 MB available

Continue? [Y/n]

Here package fonts-wqy-microhei and its alternative fonts-wqy-zenhei are
shown in two different columns. The '|' character doesn't directly
point to another package *above*, because there is no "above" to speak of.




I can't tell if this behaviour is an error, or just my mis-understanding
of meaning of '|' character.

Kamil
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.