Time to drop win32-loader ?

Didier 'OdyX' Raboud <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.linux.debian.devel.boot,gmane.linux.debian.devel.cd
Message-ID <3003326.RvMQ770SAb@mab-rare>
Hello there,
(please CC me on replies, I'm not on these lists)

(live from the d-i/debian-cd BoF)

as some of you likely remember, win32-loader is shipped on d-i and debian-cd 
images, and is added in autorun.inf for automated launch on Windows machines, 
when USB/CDs are plugged in. What it does is allow a machine booted in Windows 
to download a d-i image, put a grub image and d-i in C:/debian-installer, and 
fiddle with the (old?) Windows bootloader to allow selection of d-i upon 
reboot. It either works from the image, or downloading stuff from internet.

I haven't checked (as I don't have access to Windows machines...), but I'm 
quite confident that the Windows Bootloader fiddling is quite unlikely to work 
on modern (Secure Boot ?) machines.

That brings two sides of the question:
* should it still be shipped on amd64 netinsts, CD's, other images?
* should it still be offered on the mirrors ?
  on https://deb.debian.org/debian/tools/win32-loader/stable/
  (where it lands via dak's byhand handling upon uploads; but is manually 
  moved by ftp-master on migrations and release days)

(I orphaned win32-loader back in September, and it still doesn't have an 
official maintainer; but I'd be happy to work towards ditching it away :-P)

Best,
  OdyX
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 833 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=zTQT
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.