Re: [Artwork] result of the survey for the default artwork for Buster

Laura Arjona Reina <[email protected]> Wed, 9 Jan 2019 00:10:20 +0100
Newsgroups	gmane.linux.debian.devel.desktop
Message-ID	<[email protected]>
Hello again

El 8/1/19 a las 8:51, Laura Arjona Reina escribió:> Hi all
>
> (Please CC me, I'm not subscribed to debian-desktop mailing list).
> Note: 3rd attempt of sending this (the other messages probably dropped
> because of size of attached files), sorry if you get this several times.
>
> TL;DR
> =====
>
> *Preliminary* results of the survey, 3646 completed votes, winner of the
> survey seems to be:
>
> futurePrototype
> https://wiki.debian.org/DebianArt/Themes/futurePrototype
>
> Tally sheet is tally2.csv and the details of the condorcet calculation
> in buster_artwork_results.txt (available at
> https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/ ).
> I'm sending this here for peer review, and I'll check in the following
> hours with other tools too.
> You can inspect the responses from the original website and do your own
> calculations (see section 0 of the long version, or read the whole long
> version).
>
>
> Long version
> ============
>
> On January 6th 23:59h the survey closed and I have used the tool
> "pocket-devotee" to figure out the Condorcet winner.
> I've had to do some manual work in the export file that LimeSurvey
> provides, and I am a human, and I would like to check also with other
> tools that can calculate the Condorcet winner, so please take these
> results as preliminary (comments and corrections are welcome).
>

I have used the ericgorr website and the voteengine tool to figure out
the Condorcet winner (as explained in:
https://larjona.wordpress.com/2016/10/25/rankings-condorcet-and-free-software-calculating-the-results-for-the-stretch-artwork-survey/
) and these 2 tools also tell that the winner is "futurePrototype".

So I think that from the Condorcet-winner-guessing perspective, we can
safely say that "futurePrototype" is the winner of the Buster Artwork
Survey.

Kind regards,
-- 
Laura Arjona Reina
https://wiki.debian.org/LauraArjona



> 0.- The survey results are accessible and exportable by anybody going to
>
> https://surveys.debian.net/admin
> and using the following credentials:
> user: visitor_debian
> password: Debian10
>
> 1.- I've done this, and then clicked in "List available Surveys",
> "Debian Buster Artwork Survey", "Responses" > "Responses & Statistics"
> and then we have:
> Full responses	3646
> Incomplete responses	2754
> Total responses	6400
>
> (note: incomplete responses are the ones that chose less than 3 options
> in their ranking, or left the survey without submitting. I have
> discarded those, since the question in the survey requested to choose at
> least 3 options).
>
> 2.- Then I have gone to "Export"> "Export responses", chose export
> format CSV, Completion state: Completed responses only, and "Export
> questions as" question codes. Then I clicked on the button "Export" and
> got the file results-survey823746.csv (downloadable from
>
https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/results-survey823746.csv
> ).
>
> 3.- I copied the csv file into a new one, called "tally0.csv". Then I
> opened tally0.csv with LibreOffice Calc, and removed the columns:
> submitdate, lastpage, startlanguage, seed, and the first row (with name
> of columns). I added a new column right after the first one (with the ID
> numbers), and fulfilled it with ":". Then I saved the file as CSV
> (downloadable from
> https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/tally0.csv ).
>
> 4.- I copied the tally0.csv into a new file, called "tally1.csv". I
> opened tally1.csv with my favourite editor and did the following search
> and replace:
>
> ",:," replaced with ": "
> ",," replaced with "" (nothing)
> "," replaced with " > "
> " > \n" replaced with "\n"
>
> I saved the file (downloadable from
> https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/tally1.csv )
>
> 5.- I copied the tally1.csv into a new file, called tally2.csv.
> I opened tally2.csv with my favourite editor and did the following
> search and replace:
>
> komodo -> A
> SynchronizedMotions -> B
> Droplets -> C
> MoonLight -> D
> LostDog -> E
> futurePrototype -> F
> bestFriend -> G
> simpleOutlook -> H
> LooseTail -> I
> E-legance -> J
> Dog in Harmony -> K
>
>
> I took the order from the wiki page of the Artwork.
> I tried first using pocket-devotee with the complete names but it didn't
> work, so I did the substitution. I saved the file (downloadable from
> https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/tally2.csv )
>
>
> 6.- I cloned the tech-ctte repo from salsa:
> https://salsa.debian.org/debian/tech-ctte/ and ran the following command:
>
> ./tech-ctte/scripts/pocket-devotee \
>>  --option 'A:komodo' --option 'B:SynchronizedMotions' --option
> 'C:Droplets' \
>>  --option 'D:MoonLight' --option 'E:LostDog'  --option
> 'F:futurePrototype' \
>>  --option 'G:bestFriend'  --option 'H:simpleOutlook'  --option
> 'I:LooseTail' \
>>  --option 'J:E-legance'  --option 'K:Dog in Harmony' \
>>  --option 'Z:undefined' --default-option 'Z'< ./buster/tally2.csv >
> ./buster/buster_artwork_results.txt
>
>
> 7.- The results: buster_artwork_results.txt which shows that
> the winner of the survey is futurePrototype. (downloadable from
>
https://people.debian.org/~larjona/vote/buster-artwork/buster_artwork_results.txt
> ).
>
> Kind regards,
>
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 659 B)