Re: Missing copyright clause of debian directory

Richard Laager <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.linux.debian.devel.legal
Message-ID <[email protected]>
I've only looked at this situation for a total of five minutes prior to 
writing this email, so take this with a grain of salt. But to help you 
make forward progress...

Upstream seems to use GPL-3+ (not GPL-3). For example:
https://github.com/fxbois/web-mode/blob/a9d21841224da3295f2dd0a90022f5e435e48046/web-mode.el#L13

The existing copyright says GPL-2+ (not GPL-2).

On 2024-04-10 23:05, Xiyue Deng wrote:
> 1. whether I can add the new copyright section to cover debian/*, and

I think it is pretty typical to have a debian/* section. And if the 
licenses differ (see below), then you would _have_ to have separate 
sections.

> 2. whether I should use GPL-2 as when the previous maintainer last
> worked on this or I can use GPL-3 to match upstream version as well?

If that is what you believe applies to the debian files (which is what 
debian/copyright says today), then I would keep it as that. GPL-2+ is, 
of course, compatible with GPL-3+.

So I think you end up with something like this:

Files: *
License: GPL-3+
Copyright: fill in the upstream copyright holders

Files: debian/*
License: GPL-2+
Copyright: previous maintainer, you

-- 
Richard
OpenPGP_signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 833 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=I2Zr
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.