Re: compatibility matrix for /usr/share/common-licenses

"Serafeim Zanikolas" <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.linux.debian.devel.legal
Message-ID <[email protected]>
hi Francesco,

> I would say that the missing detail is that license compatibility is
> not a transitive relation!

indeed! I knew that but somehow it fell off my consciousness while looking at
that wikipedia diagram

> Well, before I start sending patches (for instance to reintroduce GPL-2
> in the Apache-2.0 row), some questions:
>
>  * are you going to completely ignore GPL-1 (assuming it's no longer so
>    widely adopted)? I am asking because I see that you included it in
>    the Artistic row, but not in other rows (such as GPL-3 or MPL-2.0
>    or ...)
>
>  * why did you drop LGPL-3 from the GPL-2 row? they are incompatible...
>
>  * why did you introduce LGPL-2+, LGPL-2.1, and LGPL-3 in the MPL-1.1
>    row? as far as I know, the LGPL licenses are (linking-)compatible
>    with MPL-1.1 ...

sorry, that's all sloppiness on my part, at the end of a long day. please send
me a patch, if you don't mind. as for GPL-1, either way is fine (it wasn't
included in adequate as of 8y ago, and I only see GPL-1+ references in my local
system, so it certainly seems reasonable to drop it)
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 833 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQIzBAABCAAdFiEEA2RWqo7IwLCLSFYbT59tVQ7WEioFAmaIVz4ACgkQT59tVQ7W
EiorARAA4H9rekEeoRdZH+NliYJX36jIQ7qyXnuIxHMQHy3k0tRPvNio6aovCkaZ
8MArd41yWWjdLb6rhp3oTta7FGOl8fGSSNLZ/AXf8s+w2aWFFuxHHC08tBWCVp0P
sVRNFUj6OTlRCIm9U8Ofd2yFjvbvJorq+SjI3XFrih5CVMyj1s5mn2JHk9PxzCkh
jzEuxweUCI8CUWIGELF6Hocz4IvvbaL2k0q4LW3HpBV8F9zon/5shWDOV7YZ9gkK
8+YgMLvTrgVoupuGQ7dyyTU+BRhdo+DegrjdJUOoi6F423TJH5pkh3DGv7tHCxW2
S/otGD6H2RpoE4ef0IrVBEiuBor87D/kYpb12bPUy9rGZoQfTVr89lPeU8r8q+PT
G6SLKT5gnvJH2t2Ct8/VEBKEEmE1yZKyw7xJEe7WPr6N0cjeRdORS+8bTheqd98o
LADE22qavyOJgC1AY9E2tz1LBfPBeddRKLiYLSOFzUDRU6rLI3zPwdWAGTFWb1Bj
r4kJnmN21CyqRJQtxkgBW7qBeHmz4KEtJB8/mTu4P9YtyNa4TPNqMFMk6XzQiLtZ
VQIT8CqlIfbOyygeWYZt+B8cyydTveQR9f+FimUoQjG0D8gYvFDTH+9Ntsj+nJL4
YHXyWPwR5bUX1lhXjEmgh9uuveBI/2y78ocNohef4xKvsXtcSl4=
=1PTV
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.