Re: scenefx upload dispute / request for review
Andrey Rakhmatullin <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.linux.debian.devel.mentors |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
On Fri, Aug 14, 2026 at 08:47:09PM +0000, [email protected] wrote: >Dear Debian mentors, > >I recently filed the ITP and RFS for my package 'scenefx' and uploaded the package to mentors. >Another uploader has since submitted a package that references my ITP in the changelog, but it is not a collaborative submission and should not be treated as a straightforward continuation of my work. They are actively refusing to discuss with me about it. I have noted that their salsa repository predates mine, but I don't see that as a reason to why upload on top of my perfectly fine package just to change the maintainer field and introduce more lintian warnings. > >I am requesting a review of the upload history and clarification on which submission should be considered the active package for review. Sorry if I am bothering you, I appreciate your work for debian. One of the main purposes of an ITP is to serve as a mutex. Somebody uploading a package without even filing an ITP is the losing side. That said, if mentors disallowed uploads of the same package name by different accounts it would be a much more clear situation. -- WBR, wRAR
signature.asc
(application/pgp-signature, 894 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQJhBAABCgBLFiEEtf6ieDcfC1EgtGkao+OWn23e7IYFAmp/hDctFIAAAAAAFQAP cGthLWFkZHJlc3NAZ251cGcub3Jnd3JhckBkZWJpYW4ub3JnAAoJEKPjlp9t3uyG HrAP/A74ogBdPup42jQWnkLPragMke1U1DZAvIdezthpGdluM8zMMNsLA5Ci+iHu OzBk7IHWx0l8gFW6ClWfpRK+fyjOhequiTu49jItBdWILv77NxjdKxlTTd61N8oF 0yMMhHMbpRfCHjs2cUF+8QJFn6+0qG3NOhE2qzKT20lZ5+8chW6m4RWHbKK1Oe9u 6xCz9mrru0Nlymyd+fX+IdYE9DlQoElZZ0CniVGFI4hUkA+Ko2KMZqhTsDN4Bjly 9Fw6spEa+NTGud6YDng2S22BgiCMnEs082HljrA2/8AkbzAUNWHwRrbNQUI4M4Rr hQv6LL9CdNqxzYoUil4eqZTjhtCsho5X0dw0NPCnUkB8fkCa8EXWNKYxJDJdcaNL Ja29NvEkbxAdiiQtXze456ubfCS1lzBpJY0sWEz9TezfjU/4NKoBJCwDmcPQMf9o g5dVFjZ9x17g0D4q3Eo9zf1ihrrXUDITlGVOoG7SfD6YPQ9dDBO+h5BdU3U59Ap7 0RyXMjusLNcwJAr0lmo7aW9Fizr/zWfumw78IO5eZf5evZmFBLa2ljkKZbkf4AAj 9DmLY2qQA3df/IAMJvM/GaiMEl3BmzRlilcdjojGp2M3PfqReCQF2UkDYLLmYyIL Exf7ytMPZ5K1ZqYvoJ/LQw9rfLZLfMSZ6TtuTPHlwK8sqDU1 =qygH -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----