Re: GR: Ban LLM contributions from Debian

Russ Allbery <[email protected]> Thu, 23 Jul 2026 15:51:11 -0700
Newsgroups	gmane.linux.debian.devel.vote
Organization	The Eyrie
Message-ID	<[email protected]>
Seconded.

Pierre-Elliott Bécue <[email protected]> writes:

> BEGIN BALLOT OPTION

> Accept AI contributions for Debian specific work
> ================================================

> Debian as a project does not endorse or recommend the use of generative
> AI assistants for software development, as it raises multiple concerns
> about ethics, legality, copyright, etc.

> Nevertheless, Debian acknowledges that these practices are already in
> use and here to stay. Rather than banning their use, which seems
> counter-productive and unenforceable, the project chooses to place
> responsibility on contributors and therefore defines the following
> guidelines.

> *These apply exclusively to code and work done specifically for the
> Debian project (Debian websites, applications, resources, packages,
> etc.)*. They do not apply to any upstream work. In what follows, "work"
> refers to the contributions done specifically for the Debian project.

>  - All code and work assisted by a generative AI agent or tool must
>    comply with the DFSG.
>  - The submitter is solely responsible for the submitted work and:
>    + they sufficiently evaluated and properly understand the work they
>      intend to submit, and are able to explain and defend it;
>    + they put any potential Signed-off-by tag and GPG signatures on the
>      contributions they send to the Debian infrastructure (package,
>      commit, mail, …) themselves;
>    + any content uploaded that would end up in production on Debian
>      infrastructure (main git branch, package upload) has been submitted
>      by them explicitely.
>  - Work assisted by a generative AI agent or tool should be marked as
>    such in the adapted place (commit message, changelog, …). Some
>    lightweight generative tools, such as tab-completion in Copilot, may
>    be used without the contributor realising they rely on generative AI
>    models; we therefore trust submitters to assess when this rule
>    applies. When in doubt, add such marking;
>  - No cloud-based AI shall be used when the data transmitted could
>    either be sensitive to the project (personal data, information under
>    embargo, …) or not public (debian-private discussions, …).

> END BALLOT OPTION

-- 
Russ Allbery ([email protected])              <https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/>
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 507 B)