Re: xdg-basedir for secrets

Bardot Jérôme <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.linux.xdg.devel
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Le 06/06/2019 à 23:15, Jonas DOREL a écrit :
> Hi,
>
hi
> Currently, most secrets (SSH Keys, GPG Keys, OAuth token) seems to be
> located in XDG_CONFIG_HOME.
And they should not, secrets are data not config. (for me)
>
> However I think one of the interests of the XDG basedir specification is
> to facilitate the management of those different files (backup,
> publication, mount, ...) because of the different policies applying to
> those files.
For me as far as possible all /home data should have an as strict as
possible policy.
>
> But it don't think secrets should be handled the same way as
> configuration. What do you think about adding XDG_KEYS_HOME (maybe
> .secrets or .local/secrets) and XDG_KEYS_DIR ?

If we start to manage things by there purpose (and we should (my point
of view)) some others concern will be.

if i do it for my emails, or my calendars, or my bookmark we need a
strict policy behaviours.

Which program can access at what. And what about the storage
(xml/txt/maildir/vbox etc).

For me storage should be program agnostic. (the same data should be use
by the user prefered software)

but my last email about that not look really welcome.


I m not part of anything so it’s maybe for that but i’m glad to see I m
not alone with this kind of ideas.


>
> Jonas DOREL
>
jerome


sry for my bad english

> _______________________________________________
> xdg mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/xdg

_______________________________________________
xdg mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/xdg
0x053A41EF03878A98.asc (application/pgp-keys, 3 KB)
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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=/0mo
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 899 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - https://www.enigmail.net/
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=8nGW
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.