operator-visible goals?

Keith Moore <[email protected]> Sat, 7 Feb 2004 14:17:36 -0500
Newsgroups gmane.mail.ng
Message-ID <[email protected]>
okay, it seems that

a) people are starting to state "user-visible" goals that don't seem 
relevant or recognizable to most users
b) people are starting to talk about implementation details rather than 
problem definition and goals

I don't think we're done understanding our scope  yet.

We've got a fairly good list of user-visible goals, and we can still 
add to that list if we identify more of them.  What about 
operator-visible goals?  i.e. What would those who operate the mail 
infrastructure (MTAs, submission servers, message stores, ...) want 
from a new mail system?  And what would IP network operators want from 
a new mail system?

I don't claim to understand this point-of-view as well as a user's 
point-of-view, but here's an attempt to get a list started:

- mail system operators want the mail system to be easy to configure

- mail system operators want a way to verify and test configurations 
before making them "live"

- mail system operators want the mail system to run efficiently and 
economically, without requiring substantial CPU resources, network 
bandwidth, etc. for the number of users served or messages handled

- mail system operators want the mail system to be secure, in that they 
can control access to it and that attempts at unauthorized use (a) fail 
and (b) do not significantly impact operation of the mail system or 
supporting infrastructure

- mail system operators want reliable fault detection

- mail system operators want the ability to continue operating the mail 
system in the presence of various failures

- mail system operators want effective tracing and logging to aid in 
problem diagnosis

- mail system operators want a uniform and effective interface for 
problem reporting by users

- network operators want a mail system that uses their networks 
efficiently

- network operators want a mail system that doesn't compromise the 
security or operational integrity of their networks