Re: Length of recent X-Hashcash cookies?

Justin <[email protected]> writes:

>> PS.  This message has a cookie for a gmane.org newsgroup.  This is
>> because Gnus doesn't handle X-Hashcash in news->mail gateways
>> properly.  If someone has any suggestion how it should work, that
>> would be appreciated.
>
> Is there a mapping of gmane newsgroup names to mailing list addresses
> anywhere?  If so, that could be consulted to determine the proper stamp
> resource.

The mapping isn't available in the e-mail itself (presumably it is
available on http://gmane.org somewhere).  I proposed that gmane.org
should add some headers that map newsgroup back to the list address
for this purpose, and Gnus could add a specific gmane.org-hack to
recognize that header.  Not very elegant, though.

I suppose this is a general issue with mail2news gateways and
hashcash.  Has there been any discussions for how to handle it?

>> PPS.  How about renaming X-Hashcash: to Hashcash:?  The 'X-' prefix
>> also look ugly, and was only discussed in RFC 822, not in the current
>> RFC 2822.
>
> I thought all unofficial headers are supposed to be prefixed by 'X-'.

Only according to RFC 822, but not according to RFC 2822.

Thanks,
Simon