Re: Customize the bounce message

On 12/16/2017 05:43 AM, alan wrote:
> At 23:07 15/12/2017  Friday, David Jones via spf-devel wrote:
>> Would it be possible to add a feature to allow for custom text to be add=
ed the bounce message?  I would like to make it clear when rejecting for pe=
rmerror that the sender should contact their own mail admins or tech suppor=
t and that the problem is on their end.
>>
>> Now that I am rejecting on permerrors and hard fails like the sending do=
main specified with "-all", senders are forwarding the bounce message to my=
 users via other mailboxes and asking us what is going on.
>=20
> that particular example is not the senders problem but the receivers
>=20

I didn't mean automated forwarding.  I meant they are now manually=20
forwarding the bounce message caused by an SPF permerror to say a=20
gmail.com address of theirs, then forwarding it to the original=20
recipient saying "Why did you bounce my original email?  My last email a=20
  couple of days ago went through fine."  I would like for the bounce=20
message to tell the original sender to forward this to their own mail=20
sysadmin like the openspf.net link says to do.


> if one of your users is directing people to mail him via a forwarder that=
 dosn't SRS rewrite the envelope
> then he must let you know to turn off spf checking for mail to him or mai=
l from that forwarders ip(s)
> or both when in tandem
>=20

Also, I am not talking about SPF fails that would result from forwarding=20
without SRS.  I am only talking about SPF permerrors that are caused by=20
the original envelope-from domain having a misconfigured/bad=20
syntax/duplicate record/etc.

--=20
David Jones