Re: Understanding why pdns-recursor 4.8.6 queries DS extremely often

Otto Moerbeek via Pdns-users <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.network.dns.powerdns.user
Message-ID <[email protected]> 
On Tue, Mar 12, 2024 at 08:43:20AM +0100, Thomas Mieslinger via Pdns-users wrote:

> While analyzing a spam run, I found the following queries and responses
> for the not delegated domain YALRDRK.net
> 
> For _dmarc.ja<> the queries and responses look as expected.
> 
> For default._bimi.jaqg<> a SERVFAIL is returned by instead of the
> expected NXDOMAIN.
> 
> For _bimi.jaqgs<> the gtld nameserver is queried once which is what I
> expect.
> 
> For default._bimi.jaqg<> the gtld nameservers are queried 5 times for
> the DS Record. Is there a good reason to torture .net gtld Nameservers?
> 
> > "PacketTime","Server","SrcIP","DstIP","QR","ResponseCode","Type","Question"
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:23","::ffff:10.74.42.28","::ffff:172.19.254.2",0,0,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:23","::ffff:172.19.254.2","::ffff:10.74.42.28",1,3,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:10.74.42.31","::ffff:172.19.255.2",0,0,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:172.19.255.2","::ffff:10.74.42.31",1,3,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:10.74.42.31","::ffff:172.19.255.2",0,0,16,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:172.19.255.2","::ffff:10.74.42.31",1,2,16,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:23","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.42.93.30",0,0,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:23","::ffff:192.42.93.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,16,"_dmarc.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"_bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"_bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,16,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,16,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:82.165.226.66","::ffff:192.54.112.30",0,0,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","::ffff:192.54.112.30","::ffff:82.165.226.66",1,3,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","2001:8d8:5c1:453:82:165:226:66","2001:502:8cc::30",0,0,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> > "2024-03-09 19:31:55","2001:502:8cc::30","2001:8d8:5c1:453:82:165:226:66",1,3,43,"default._bimi.jaqgsfzaxlvvegquwrjaaztnpaskgocqfvregpwqbplmwqahqe.YALRDRK.net."
> 
> dnssec=process
> root-nx-trust=on
> nothing-below-nxdomain=no
> qname-minimization=no
> 
> If you need the full config or packetcapture, please ask.
> 
> Thanks for your insights
> 
> Cheers
> 
> Thomas

Hoi,

Probably the full config plus a trace doing the query will help more,
as it gives insight in the decision process of the recursor. I'm also
a bit confused. You say YALRDRK.net is not delegated, but I do see NS
records for it in the .net zone. Or did the delegation status of the domain change
recently?

;; AUTHORITY SECTION:
YALRDRK.net.            172800  IN      NS      ns11.abovedomains.com.
YALRDRK.net.            172800  IN      NS      ns12.abovedomains.com.

	-Otto
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.