Re: A "Railway Model." Re: Codel and Wireless

you have to read the literature  - the data center tcp variants that
avoid incast do so by passing l2 feedback (which is part of the
ethernet spec - you can send a control frame which indicates a new
inter-frame gap) through the IP layer and on to TCP sources (actually,
it doesn't HAVE to work that way- you can just  have per-flow queues
in the soruce machine and apply the dynamic inter-frame gap/delay
differently to different queues....

so there's no layer 2 congestion +control+ - just queue feedback that
is from l2 and a mechanism to pace packets...

actually, you could do this in DCF in wifi too:)

In missive <[email protected]>, Detlef Bosau typed:

 >>Am 07.12.2013 17:04, schrieb Jon Crowcroft:
 >>> you might want to read about how people use layer two congestion
 >>> signaling from L2 (only) switches to  give feedback to TCP which then
 >>> uses a distributed scheduler to avoid the incast problem alluded to...
 >>>
 >>> yes, gasp, layer violation - but it works. so engineers like it
 >>
 >>I don't mind layer violation.
 >>
 >>However, a L3 resource problem is slightly different from L2 flow control.
 >>
 >>Only to mention two issues:
 >>
 >>1.: Passing L2 congestion information to L3 is likely to end up in
 >>source quench or the like.
 >>
 >>Which sources are throttled? To which degree? What happens to traffic
 >>which is not associated to any flow?
 >>
 >>2.: The very first problem met when you want to employ L2 flow control
 >>for upper layers is Head of Line Blocking. To my understanding, this is
 >>THE very reason why the use of L2 congestion control was silently
 >>abandoned in the turn from Cerf's catenet to RFC 791
 >>
 >>
 >>-- 
 >>------------------------------------------------------------------
 >>Detlef Bosau
 >>Galileistraße 30   
 >>70565 Stuttgart                            Tel.:   +49 711 5208031
 >>                                           mobile: +49 172 6819937
 >>                                           skype:     detlef.bosau
 >>                                           ICQ:          566129673
 >>[email protected]                     http://www.detlef-bosau.de
 >>

 cheers

   jon