RE: export in csv does not save details

"Guy Harris" <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.network.ethereal.user
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Franz Mayer wrote:

> And I don't get the point, why it should not be possible to export packet
> details in CSV.

The reason why the UI should not offer that possibility is that *no code
has been written to implement it*.  At least one reason why no code has
been written to implement it is that what "it" means isn't yet defined -
see below (and see my previous mail).

> It would be a nice feature, because I wanted to do some
> calculation on my own and therefore a CSV (can be opened in Calc or Excel)
> could be helpful!

See my previous mail for why, although it's certainly a *useful* feature,
it's not an *easy* feature to implement.  You can't just give it a list of
field names and say "export these", because that doesn't answer the
question of what "export these" means when, for one of "these", there's
*more than one instance* in the protocol tree.  Should it always export
the first one?  Should it always export the last one?  Should it export
all of them - and, if so, how?  It probably couldn't use commas to
separate the different values, unless CSV is "defined" to allow a "value"
to be a comma-separated list in brackets, or something such as that.  Or
should it simply fail if more than one instance of the field is found? 
Note that, as I indicated in a previous message, if "export packet fields
as CSV" failed if more than one instance of a field existed in the packet,
that would prevent exporting IP addresses if you have any form of
tunneling with two layers of IP header.
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.