Re: unsuitable protocols and standards that block innovation

t3sserakt <[email protected]> Sat, 16 Mar 2024 18:57:00 +0000

Newsgroups	gmane.network.gnunet.devel
Message-ID	<[email protected]>

On 16.03.24 18:54, MSavoritias wrote:
> On 3/16/24 17:08, carlo von lynX wrote:
>
>> On Fri, Mar 15, 2024 at 04:19:21PM +0200, MSavoritias wrote:
>
>>>> Federation has failed us big time and it is all the reason why 
>>>> GNUnet exists.
>>> By federation i mean that the room is hosted by all participants. We 
>>> can
>>> call it distributed too.
Maybe you should have a look onto 
https://docs.gnunet.org/latest/users/messenger.html and 
https://www.gnunet.org/en/news/2024-03-messenger-gtk-0.9.0.html
>>> Any future architectures should make sure that the spam message 
>>> doesn't even
>>> reach the recipient to begin with.
>> That's what we've been preaching to the advocates of the
>> broken Internet for years. Glad you arrived to the same
>> conclusions as us.
>
> Does GNUnet plan to be a network of consent with capabilities? Because 
> right now its just an open permissionless hellscape unless you turn on 
> f2f but f2f is hopelessy worse than networks of consent.

The foundation for the way GNUnet is built are these design principles

 1. GNUnet must be implemented asFree Software
    <https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html>.
 2. GNUnet must minimize the amount of personally identifiable
    information exposed.
 3. GNUnet must be fully distributed and resilient to external attacks
    and rogue participants.
 4. GNUnet must be self-organizing and not depend on administrators or
    centralized infrastructure.
 5. GNUnet must inform the user which other participants have to be
    trusted when establishing private communications.
 6. GNUnet must be open and permit new peers to join.
 7. GNUnet must support a diverse range of applications and devices.
 8. GNUnet must use compartmentalization to protect sensitive information.
 9. The GNUnet architecture must be resource efficient.
10. GNUnet must provide incentives for peers to contribute more
    resources than they consume.

You must be careful when to talk about permissionless. If you like to 
have a meta data protecting and censorship resistant network you need 
some basic network where no peer has to be allowed to join the network. 
The communication in this layer is not about communication between 
applications (users) talking to each other, but communication needed to 
fulfill the above principles. Nevertheless an application can implement 
what your are trying to achieve. See the link to the messenger service 
and application above.

- t3sserakt

P.S.: F2F was removed

OpenPGP_0x524982A0100F7490.asc (application/pgp-keys, 3 KB)

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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=lgGI
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

OpenPGP_signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 840 B)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=iZeG
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----