Re: network from scratch

t3sserakt <[email protected]> Tue, 1 Nov 2022 09:19:38 +0000

Newsgroups	gmane.network.gnunet.general
Message-ID	<[email protected]>

> ------------------------------
>
> Message: 2
> Date: Mon, 31 Oct 2022 15:45:15 +0000
> From:[email protected]
> To: Martin Schanzenbach<[email protected]>
> Cc:[email protected],[email protected]
> Subject: Re: network from scratch
> Message-ID:<Y1/[email protected]>
> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
>
> Aha so adding -f to the gnunet-peer -s -g makes it output the hello.
>
> And that URI is accepted by gnunet-peer -p
>
> Now the peer is listed with gnunet-peer (-f)
>
> Now peer A and B has both peer A and B in their peerinfo lists.
>
> However, the peer A is still not being sent by the hostlist (after retstarting
> the nodes), still only the Y924 is being sent.
>
> Then I changed the URIs fromgnunet://hello-friend  tognunet://hello.
> Now the peers get sent with the hostlist.

I do not get why - in F2F mode - you are doing that. What is the content 
of friends.txt?

Can you please elaborate more on your use case.

I must admit, that I never tried out the F2F mode.

>
> However, peer B still does not connect to peer A during bootstrap, in spite of
> getting the peer info.
>
> Also of note:
>
> 1. If I restart the peer A, again only Y924 is seems to be
> left in the peerinfo db - that is, only Y924 is being sent to B.
>
> 2. After achieving connection, if I restart the nodes they don't
> reconnect automatically.
>
> --
>
> So to summarize, to connect I can do:
>
> PEER=`gnunet -s -g -f -c peer1.conf | sed s/hello-friend/hello/g`
> gnunet -p $PEER
>
> BUT the association does NOT seem to persist across sessions.

"In the pure "friend-to-friend" mode, your peer will ONLY connect to 
peers from a list of friends specified in the configuration." [1]

In pure F2F mode the hostlist server does not matter. Also the peerstore 
does not. Only your friends.txt file. At least that's what I read from 
documentation.

- t3sserakt

[1] 
https://docs.gnunet.org/users/configuration.html?highlight=friends#configuring-the-friend-to-friend-f2f-mode

OpenPGP_0x524982A0100F7490.asc (application/pgp-keys, 3 KB)

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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=lgGI
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

OpenPGP_signature (application/pgp-signature, 840 B) - not displayed