Re: Proposed XMPP Extension: End-to-End Encrypted Contacts Metadata

>URL: https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/contacts-e2e.html

This seems basically the same as bookmarks2. We have previously discussed 
putting contacts in bookmarks2 and some have complained that they assume 
everything in bookmarks2 is a MUC and so it's not allowed there.

In the interest of reducing duplication we've then discussed putting 
extensions in the classic roster and then the client merges from both 
sources as today.

Now if we want to move contacts into pubsub anyway it feels like what we 
really want is boomarks3: bookmarks2 but with wording that makes it clear 
that not everything in there is a MUC. This solves all the extended metadata 
questions that have been coming up over recent years while also making both 
things possible to encrypt with pubsub encryption methods as desired.

_______________________________________________
Standards mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=2Buj
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----