Re: Proposed XMPP Extension: XMPP Decentralized ID (XID)

--===============3345285976319715823==
Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha256;
	protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="I4mLgJBnMJcCGb2c"
Content-Disposition: inline


--I4mLgJBnMJcCGb2c
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed
Content-Disposition: inline
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

>I need that for serverless, but it has several other use cases as explaine=
d in
>the protoXEP, and we don't have equivalent AFAIK for that (OX would be the
>closest, but more complicate and difficult to use in those case).

I think it's not going to make much sense to me until I see it in the=20
context it's actually going to be used in... even if being a separate XEP=
=20
still makes sense.

>It's inspired from Peer ID from libP2P, and relatively simple to implement=
 and
>use.
>
>> I'm also concerned about formatting them as valid JIDs since this may get
>> confusing on the live network.
>
>That's why a `.internal` TLD was used for, but as pointed out by other in =
this
>thread, it's not the best choice. Probably `.alt` would be a better fit, as
>it's a non-DNS namespace.

But even so it still looks like a JID and can parse as a JID and could end=
=20
up in a part of the code that expects it to be a JID... I'm not sure this i=
s=20
what we would want if it's for other purposes?

--I4mLgJBnMJcCGb2c
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=0/wH
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--I4mLgJBnMJcCGb2c--

--===============3345285976319715823==
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

_______________________________________________
Standards mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

--===============3345285976319715823==--