Re: Debug build of silc toolkit fails to connect (Incorrect Signature)
Brian Reed <[email protected]> Wed, 10 Dec 2008 10:45:47 -0800
| Newsgroups | gmane.network.silc.devel |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
: I have the latest silc toolkit code (1.1.8) and am building in VS : 2005. When I build in Release mode, it connects and runs fine. When I : build in debug mode (defining SILC_DEBUG), the server disconnects me : during the key exchange with the error message "Error Incorrect : signature (9) received during key exchange". I am using the exact same : server (Ubuntu, 1.1.14) and settings on each attempt. How is the : signature calculated? What tests can I do to figure out what is going wrong? : For starters, output the SKE debugs by setting *ske* debug string with silc_log_set_debug_string and call also silc_log_debug_hexdump. Give the same debug string with -d to silcd. I have attached the debug output from both the client and server to this email. I assumed it would also be useful to have the server's hexdump, so when I debugged it,I included that. Thanks for your time. Brian _______________________________________________________________________ Info: https://lists.silcnet.org/mailman/listinfo/silc-announce Archive: https://lists.silcnet.org/pipermail/silc-announce FAQ: http://silcnet.org/support/faq/
ClientHexDump.txt
(text/plain, 11.6 KB)
09:53:20 Silc Client Service Running in Debug Mode start 09:53:35 NSilc Client Created. System: Status: Connecting to port 706 of server 10.0.201.164 Connecting to port 706 of server 10.0.201.164 System: Status: Client running. Client running. 09:53:47 NSilc Client Started. 06:36:25 silc_ske_alloc:1009: Allocating new Key Exchange object 06:36:25 silc_ske_initiator:1808: Start SKE as initiator 06:36:25 silc_ske_assemble_security_properties:828: Assembling KE Start Payload 06:36:25 silc_ske_st_initiator_start:1144: Start 06:36:25 silc_ske_payload_start_encode:34: Encoding KE Start Payload silc_ske_payload_start_encode:80: KE Start Payload 00000000 00 04 01 44 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...D.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 38 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.8 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 2B 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t.+diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 2C 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D n-group1,diffie- 00000050 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 32 00 07 hellman-group2.. 00000060 72 73 61 2C 72 73 61 00 7C 61 65 73 2D 32 35 36 rsa,rsa.|aes-256 00000070 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 74 72 -ctr,aes-192-ctr 00000080 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 ,aes-128-ctr,aes 00000090 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 -256-cbc,aes-192 000000A0 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 -cbc,aes-128-cbc 000000B0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-256-cbc 000000C0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-192-cbc 000000D0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-128-cbc 000000E0 2C 6E 6F 6E 65 00 0F 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 73 68 ,none..sha256,sh 000000F0 61 31 2C 6D 64 35 00 46 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 a1,md5.Fhmac-sha 00000100 32 35 36 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 31 256-96,hmac-sha1 00000110 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 2D 39 36 2C -96,hmac-md5-96, 00000120 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 hmac-sha256,hmac 00000130 2D 73 68 61 31 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 00 04 -sha1,hmac-md5.. 00000140 6E 6F 6E 65 none 06:36:25 silc_ske_st_initiator_start:1182: Waiting for responder proposal 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase1:1201: Start 06:36:26 silc_ske_payload_start_decode:98: Decoding Key Exchange Start Payload silc_ske_payload_start_decode:101: KE Start Payload 00000000 00 04 00 74 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...t.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 35 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.5 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 15 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t..diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 00 03 72 73 61 00 0B 61 n-group1..rsa..a 00000050 65 73 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 74 72 00 06 73 68 61 32 es-256-ctr..sha2 00000060 35 36 00 0E 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2D 56..hmac-sha256- 00000070 39 36 00 00 96.. 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase2:1341: Start 06:36:26 silc_ske_create_rnd:633: Creating random number 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase2:1378: Computing e = g ^ x mod p 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase2:1406: We are doing mutual authentication 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase2:1407: Computing HASH_i value 06:36:26 silc_ske_make_hash:674: Start silc_ske_make_hash:760: hash buf 00000000 00 04 01 44 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...D.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 38 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.8 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 2B 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t.+diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 2C 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D n-group1,diffie- 00000050 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 32 00 07 hellman-group2.. 00000060 72 73 61 2C 72 73 61 00 7C 61 65 73 2D 32 35 36 rsa,rsa.|aes-256 00000070 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 74 72 -ctr,aes-192-ctr 00000080 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 ,aes-128-ctr,aes 00000090 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 -256-cbc,aes-192 000000A0 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 -cbc,aes-128-cbc 000000B0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-256-cbc 000000C0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-192-cbc 000000D0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-128-cbc 000000E0 2C 6E 6F 6E 65 00 0F 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 73 68 ,none..sha256,sh 000000F0 61 31 2C 6D 64 35 00 46 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 a1,md5.Fhmac-sha 00000100 32 35 36 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 31 256-96,hmac-sha1 00000110 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 2D 39 36 2C -96,hmac-md5-96, 00000120 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 hmac-sha256,hmac 00000130 2D 73 68 61 31 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 00 04 -sha1,hmac-md5.. 00000140 6E 6F 6E 65 00 00 01 50 00 03 72 73 61 00 3F 55 none...P..rsa.?U 00000150 4E 3D 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 48 4E 3D 6E 65 6D 65 N=breed, HN=neme 00000160 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 2C 20 52 4E 3D sis.futurec, RN= 00000170 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 45 3D 62 72 65 65 64 40 6E breed, E=breed@n 00000180 65 6D 65 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 00 00 emesis.futurec.. 00000190 00 02 FF FD 00 00 01 00 83 5B BB 79 D5 F8 7F 73 .........[.y...s 000001A0 17 BB F1 F4 AE D1 46 22 B2 65 2C 4C AF 3B AA 8A ......F".e,L.;.. 000001B0 28 94 67 17 BC F9 2D 88 22 3E 37 92 B4 78 24 F6 (.g...-.">7..x$. 000001C0 2B 06 92 D8 15 B1 21 12 82 9E C6 E9 24 C4 5B 24 +.....!.....$.[$ 000001D0 77 34 F1 B9 BC B7 BC E6 4C 6D C1 6C 41 76 E5 4E w4......Lm.lAv.N 000001E0 77 51 A9 CB 95 D2 C9 A8 59 1A D8 40 CA 45 AA 3B [email protected].; 000001F0 7F 2B 2F F2 EB C2 23 04 30 37 DE 6E 75 30 D0 FB .+/...#.07.nu0.. 00000200 34 E2 C2 23 DB D6 26 B7 47 40 8D BD 46 83 53 74 4..#..&[email protected] 00000210 46 78 71 5E BE B0 1B 85 C5 27 E8 20 A3 60 D4 3F Fxq^.....'. .`.? 00000220 1A 81 F1 CE 28 06 6C 6E 24 E3 08 39 38 50 BA 9D ....(.ln$..98P.. 00000230 D8 29 8F FD C7 ED 29 BE E4 AF 3C 0B E8 A5 F4 D3 .)....)...<..... 00000240 22 FE 73 34 17 D7 20 C8 3A 87 AF 9D 54 63 B9 C9 ".s4.. .:...Tc.. 00000250 C3 00 CA EA 8E 28 39 E3 4D 5F 70 C7 0E 4A DF 8D .....(9.M_p..J.. 00000260 3C 43 4C A2 A8 02 88 C6 66 32 2B 98 BC AD AB E9 <CL.....f2+..... 00000270 DE 14 FF 88 C6 DB 1F 18 CB 10 AE CE 2F E7 44 4F ............/.DO 00000280 D9 A9 ED 2D 03 F7 CD 0A E9 91 43 D5 BB D0 5A 8B ...-......C...Z. 00000290 15 4F ED 19 97 E6 FD 6D 61 2A 67 9E 03 CB 44 1A .O.....ma*g...D. 000002A0 B6 4B 75 B9 8E E1 2E 9B 61 8B 64 EA 00 27 C9 D0 .Ku.....a.d..'.. 000002B0 77 9F 0F 32 CC 73 7E 98 F1 D8 2B 5C 8E 2A 8E DF w..2.s~...+\.*.. 000002C0 A9 24 78 B8 3D 5B BD A5 F4 37 13 4D F7 3B 9A 82 .$x.=[...7.M.;.. 000002D0 F8 A1 E0 EC 30 F4 CE 09 A7 53 04 43 31 04 60 53 ....0....S.C1.`S 000002E0 CE 40 8D FC E8 72 A7 FF 42 05 F7 69 FF BC 87 2F [email protected].../ 000002F0 1D 9F E3 38 E9 DC 8E 0C 60 65 DA 08 C5 32 D0 C0 ...8....`e...2.. 00000300 0B 71 54 F1 9C B1 24 2D FB 86 AD 44 A7 7B 84 84 .qT...$-...D.{.. 00000310 21 D2 3A 9F 1A 02 33 BF !.:...3. silc_ske_make_hash:774: HASH_i 00000000 66 AD 8F 5E 9B 00 73 90 90 B5 40 9A 2D 97 49 87 f..^[email protected]. 00000010 F9 B6 D3 1F F0 C1 47 7F 66 3E 1D 4F B2 F8 E2 E2 ......G.f>.O.... 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_phase2:1413: Signing HASH_i value 06:36:26 silc_ske_payload_ke_encode:200: Encoding KE Payload silc_ske_payload_ke_encode:244: KE Payload 00000000 01 54 00 01 00 00 01 50 00 03 72 73 61 00 3F 55 .T.....P..rsa.?U 00000010 4E 3D 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 48 4E 3D 6E 65 6D 65 N=breed, HN=neme 00000020 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 2C 20 52 4E 3D sis.futurec, RN= 00000030 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 45 3D 62 72 65 65 64 40 6E breed, E=breed@n 00000040 65 6D 65 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 00 00 emesis.futurec.. 00000050 00 02 FF FD 00 00 01 00 83 5B BB 79 D5 F8 7F 73 .........[.y...s 00000060 17 BB F1 F4 AE D1 46 22 B2 65 2C 4C AF 3B AA 8A ......F".e,L.;.. 00000070 28 94 67 17 BC F9 2D 88 22 3E 37 92 B4 78 24 F6 (.g...-.">7..x$. 00000080 2B 06 92 D8 15 B1 21 12 82 9E C6 E9 24 C4 5B 24 +.....!.....$.[$ 00000090 77 34 F1 B9 BC B7 BC E6 4C 6D C1 6C 41 76 E5 4E w4......Lm.lAv.N 000000A0 77 51 A9 CB 95 D2 C9 A8 59 1A D8 40 CA 45 AA 3B [email protected].; 000000B0 7F 2B 2F F2 EB C2 23 04 30 37 DE 6E 75 30 D0 FB .+/...#.07.nu0.. 000000C0 34 E2 C2 23 DB D6 26 B7 47 40 8D BD 46 83 53 74 4..#..&[email protected] 000000D0 46 78 71 5E BE B0 1B 85 C5 27 E8 20 A3 60 D4 3F Fxq^.....'. .`.? 000000E0 1A 81 F1 CE 28 06 6C 6E 24 E3 08 39 38 50 BA 9D ....(.ln$..98P.. 000000F0 D8 29 8F FD C7 ED 29 BE E4 AF 3C 0B E8 A5 F4 D3 .)....)...<..... 00000100 22 FE 73 34 17 D7 20 C8 3A 87 AF 9D 54 63 B9 C9 ".s4.. .:...Tc.. 00000110 C3 00 CA EA 8E 28 39 E3 4D 5F 70 C7 0E 4A DF 8D .....(9.M_p..J.. 00000120 3C 43 4C A2 A8 02 88 C6 66 32 2B 98 BC AD AB E9 <CL.....f2+..... 00000130 DE 14 FF 88 C6 DB 1F 18 CB 10 AE CE 2F E7 44 4F ............/.DO 00000140 D9 A9 ED 2D 03 F7 CD 0A E9 91 43 D5 BB D0 5A 8B ...-......C...Z. 00000150 15 4F ED 19 97 E6 FD 6D 00 80 61 2A 67 9E 03 CB .O.....m..a*g... 00000160 44 1A B6 4B 75 B9 8E E1 2E 9B 61 8B 64 EA 00 27 D..Ku.....a.d..' 00000170 C9 D0 77 9F 0F 32 CC 73 7E 98 F1 D8 2B 5C 8E 2A ..w..2.s~...+\.* 00000180 8E DF A9 24 78 B8 3D 5B BD A5 F4 37 13 4D F7 3B ...$x.=[...7.M.; 00000190 9A 82 F8 A1 E0 EC 30 F4 CE 09 A7 53 04 43 31 04 ......0....S.C1. 000001A0 60 53 CE 40 8D FC E8 72 A7 FF 42 05 F7 69 FF BC `[email protected].. 000001B0 87 2F 1D 9F E3 38 E9 DC 8E 0C 60 65 DA 08 C5 32 ./...8....`e...2 000001C0 D0 C0 0B 71 54 F1 9C B1 24 2D FB 86 AD 44 A7 7B ...qT...$-...D.{ 000001D0 84 84 21 D2 3A 9F 1A 02 33 BF 01 00 02 49 88 51 ..!.:...3....I.Q 000001E0 D4 17 23 D1 89 C9 BD C2 8F 6D 67 C3 A7 2F 65 06 ..#......mg../e. 000001F0 2F D1 48 3E AB 37 72 31 ED 84 59 81 56 D0 E5 B0 /.H>.7r1..Y.V... 00000200 86 A4 C0 28 AE EB BA 04 92 70 CD A2 53 91 4F 37 ...(.....p..S.O7 00000210 67 D3 98 5F 3A 48 FE C1 F3 AD F0 E2 96 40 36 7A g.._:H.......@6z 00000220 4B D9 7A 3F EF 40 DB 3D 4E F8 C5 BE 7E AD 5F E2 K.z?.@.=N...~._. 00000230 6D 15 47 A2 8C 4E 2B 16 B8 3F CD 6C 2A 63 D9 2D m.G..N+..?.l*c.- 00000240 09 87 FF EC A4 91 FC 73 09 25 AC 15 D5 61 A5 DD .......s.%...a.. 00000250 3F B1 E6 8A 7B 33 A4 12 70 86 C1 13 30 A9 70 61 ?...{3..p...0.pa 00000260 6F 1D 28 0A FB 21 C8 52 10 F6 E4 F4 6F 59 C8 7E o.(..!.R....oY.~ 00000270 F1 B1 54 30 E8 45 1D 33 9D 6F 8C E7 51 C0 D7 9A ..T0.E.3.o..Q... 00000280 8E BD F2 4A 11 6D AB 16 70 EB B5 26 07 37 05 FD ...J.m..p..&.7.. 00000290 6E DD 99 E4 8C 62 DF 34 B0 7A EC E2 F0 04 9B D4 n....b.4.z...... 000002A0 58 AA 5C 23 37 B9 86 61 83 B8 53 D6 7F 6A 47 22 X.\#7..a..S..jG" 000002B0 D8 26 C1 13 E9 F5 9A 90 0A A1 52 67 0C 86 03 03 .&........Rg.... 000002C0 00 64 68 B8 80 7F FE CA 7F 81 5F F9 59 F9 0D 2E .dh......._.Y... 000002D0 C7 57 F4 39 A1 02 1E 3D 59 50 47 72 .W.9...=YPGr 06:36:26 silc_ske_st_initiator_failure:1790: Error Incorrect signature (9) recei ved during key exchange System: Error: Error during key exchange with 10.0.201.164: Incorrect signature Error during key exchange with 10.0.201.164: Incorrect signature 06:36:26 silc_ske_free:1039: Freeing Key Exchange object 06:36:26 silc_ske_free:1039: Freeing Key Exchange object
ServerHexDump.txt
(text/plain, 12.2 KB)
[Logging] [Info] SILC Server started [Logging] [Info] Incoming connection 10.0.201.21 (10.0.201.21) 09:53:52 silc_ske_alloc:1013: Allocating new Key Exchange object 09:53:52 silc_ske_responder:2416: Start SKE as responder 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_start:1862: Start 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase1:1890: Start 09:53:52 silc_ske_payload_start_decode:98: Decoding Key Exchange Start Payload silc_ske_payload_start_decode:101: KE Start Payload 00000000 00 04 01 44 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...D.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 38 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.8 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 2B 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t.+diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 2C 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D n-group1,diffie- 00000050 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 32 00 07 hellman-group2.. 00000060 72 73 61 2C 72 73 61 00 7C 61 65 73 2D 32 35 36 rsa,rsa.|aes-256 00000070 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 74 72 -ctr,aes-192-ctr 00000080 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 ,aes-128-ctr,aes 00000090 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 -256-cbc,aes-192 000000A0 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 -cbc,aes-128-cbc 000000B0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-256-cbc 000000C0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-192-cbc 000000D0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-128-cbc 000000E0 2C 6E 6F 6E 65 00 0F 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 73 68 ,none..sha256,sh 000000F0 61 31 2C 6D 64 35 00 46 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 a1,md5.Fhmac-sha 00000100 32 35 36 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 31 256-96,hmac-sha1 00000110 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 2D 39 36 2C -96,hmac-md5-96, 00000120 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 hmac-sha256,hmac 00000130 2D 73 68 61 31 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 00 04 -sha1,hmac-md5.. 00000140 6E 6F 6E 65 none 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase1:1925: Force mutual authentication 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:213: Parsing KE Start Payload 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:303: Proposed KE group `diffie-hellman-group1' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:306: Found KE group `diffie-hellman-group1' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:357: Proposed PKCS alg `rsa' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:360: Found PKCS alg `rsa' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:405: Proposed encryption alg `aes-256-ctr' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:408: Found encryption alg `aes-256-ctr' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:462: Proposed hash alg `sha256' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:465: Found hash alg `sha256' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:521: Proposed HMAC `hmac-sha256-96' 09:53:52 silc_ske_select_security_properties:524: Found HMAC `hmac-sha256-96' 09:53:52 silc_ske_payload_start_encode:34: Encoding KE Start Payload silc_ske_payload_start_encode:80: KE Start Payload 00000000 00 04 00 74 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...t.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 35 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.5 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 15 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t..diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 00 03 72 73 61 00 0B 61 n-group1..rsa..a 00000050 65 73 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 74 72 00 06 73 68 61 32 es-256-ctr..sha2 00000060 35 36 00 0E 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2D 56..hmac-sha256- 00000070 39 36 00 00 96.. 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase2:2003: Start 09:53:52 silc_ske_payload_ke_decode:266: Decoding Key Exchange Payload silc_ske_payload_ke_decode:268: KE Payload 00000000 01 54 00 01 00 00 01 50 00 03 72 73 61 00 3F 55 .T.....P..rsa.?U 00000010 4E 3D 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 48 4E 3D 6E 65 6D 65 N=breed, HN=neme 00000020 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 2C 20 52 4E 3D sis.futurec, RN= 00000030 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 45 3D 62 72 65 65 64 40 6E breed, E=breed@n 00000040 65 6D 65 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 00 00 emesis.futurec.. 00000050 00 02 FF FD 00 00 01 00 83 5B BB 79 D5 F8 7F 73 .........[.y...s 00000060 17 BB F1 F4 AE D1 46 22 B2 65 2C 4C AF 3B AA 8A ......F".e,L.;.. 00000070 28 94 67 17 BC F9 2D 88 22 3E 37 92 B4 78 24 F6 (.g...-.">7..x$. 00000080 2B 06 92 D8 15 B1 21 12 82 9E C6 E9 24 C4 5B 24 +.....!.....$.[$ 00000090 77 34 F1 B9 BC B7 BC E6 4C 6D C1 6C 41 76 E5 4E w4......Lm.lAv.N 000000A0 77 51 A9 CB 95 D2 C9 A8 59 1A D8 40 CA 45 AA 3B [email protected].; 000000B0 7F 2B 2F F2 EB C2 23 04 30 37 DE 6E 75 30 D0 FB .+/...#.07.nu0.. 000000C0 34 E2 C2 23 DB D6 26 B7 47 40 8D BD 46 83 53 74 4..#..&[email protected] 000000D0 46 78 71 5E BE B0 1B 85 C5 27 E8 20 A3 60 D4 3F Fxq^.....'. .`.? 000000E0 1A 81 F1 CE 28 06 6C 6E 24 E3 08 39 38 50 BA 9D ....(.ln$..98P.. 000000F0 D8 29 8F FD C7 ED 29 BE E4 AF 3C 0B E8 A5 F4 D3 .)....)...<..... 00000100 22 FE 73 34 17 D7 20 C8 3A 87 AF 9D 54 63 B9 C9 ".s4.. .:...Tc.. 00000110 C3 00 CA EA 8E 28 39 E3 4D 5F 70 C7 0E 4A DF 8D .....(9.M_p..J.. 00000120 3C 43 4C A2 A8 02 88 C6 66 32 2B 98 BC AD AB E9 <CL.....f2+..... 00000130 DE 14 FF 88 C6 DB 1F 18 CB 10 AE CE 2F E7 44 4F ............/.DO 00000140 D9 A9 ED 2D 03 F7 CD 0A E9 91 43 D5 BB D0 5A 8B ...-......C...Z. 00000150 15 4F ED 19 97 E6 FD 6D 00 80 61 2A 67 9E 03 CB .O.....m..a*g... 00000160 44 1A B6 4B 75 B9 8E E1 2E 9B 61 8B 64 EA 00 27 D..Ku.....a.d..' 00000170 C9 D0 77 9F 0F 32 CC 73 7E 98 F1 D8 2B 5C 8E 2A ..w..2.s~...+\.* 00000180 8E DF A9 24 78 B8 3D 5B BD A5 F4 37 13 4D F7 3B ...$x.=[...7.M.; 00000190 9A 82 F8 A1 E0 EC 30 F4 CE 09 A7 53 04 43 31 04 ......0....S.C1. 000001A0 60 53 CE 40 8D FC E8 72 A7 FF 42 05 F7 69 FF BC `[email protected].. 000001B0 87 2F 1D 9F E3 38 E9 DC 8E 0C 60 65 DA 08 C5 32 ./...8....`e...2 000001C0 D0 C0 0B 71 54 F1 9C B1 24 2D FB 86 AD 44 A7 7B ...qT...$-...D.{ 000001D0 84 84 21 D2 3A 9F 1A 02 33 BF 01 00 02 49 88 51 ..!.:...3....I.Q 000001E0 D4 17 23 D1 89 C9 BD C2 8F 6D 67 C3 A7 2F 65 06 ..#......mg../e. 000001F0 2F D1 48 3E AB 37 72 31 ED 84 59 81 56 D0 E5 B0 /.H>.7r1..Y.V... 00000200 86 A4 C0 28 AE EB BA 04 92 70 CD A2 53 91 4F 37 ...(.....p..S.O7 00000210 67 D3 98 5F 3A 48 FE C1 F3 AD F0 E2 96 40 36 7A g.._:H.......@6z 00000220 4B D9 7A 3F EF 40 DB 3D 4E F8 C5 BE 7E AD 5F E2 K.z?.@.=N...~._. 00000230 6D 15 47 A2 8C 4E 2B 16 B8 3F CD 6C 2A 63 D9 2D m.G..N+..?.l*c.- 00000240 09 87 FF EC A4 91 FC 73 09 25 AC 15 D5 61 A5 DD .......s.%...a.. 00000250 3F B1 E6 8A 7B 33 A4 12 70 86 C1 13 30 A9 70 61 ?...{3..p...0.pa 00000260 6F 1D 28 0A FB 21 C8 52 10 F6 E4 F4 6F 59 C8 7E o.(..!.R....oY.~ 00000270 F1 B1 54 30 E8 45 1D 33 9D 6F 8C E7 51 C0 D7 9A ..T0.E.3.o..Q... 00000280 8E BD F2 4A 11 6D AB 16 70 EB B5 26 07 37 05 FD ...J.m..p..&.7.. 00000290 6E DD 99 E4 8C 62 DF 34 B0 7A EC E2 F0 04 9B D4 n....b.4.z...... 000002A0 58 AA 5C 23 37 B9 86 61 83 B8 53 D6 7F 6A 47 22 X.\#7..a..S..jG" 000002B0 D8 26 C1 13 E9 F5 9A 90 0A A1 52 67 0C 86 03 03 .&........Rg.... 000002C0 00 64 68 B8 80 7F FE CA 7F 81 5F F9 59 F9 0D 2E .dh......._.Y... 000002D0 C7 57 F4 39 A1 02 1E 3D 59 50 47 72 .W.9...=YPGr 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase2:2034: We are doing mutual authentication 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase2:2061: Verifying public key 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase4:2132: Public key is authentic 09:53:52 silc_ske_make_hash:678: Start silc_ske_make_hash:764: hash buf 00000000 00 04 01 44 AB 62 02 AC 15 A0 D4 EB CB DF 91 E0 ...D.b.......... 00000010 F0 9B FB 18 00 1B 53 49 4C 43 2D 31 2E 32 2D 31 ......SILC-1.2-1 00000020 2E 31 2E 38 20 73 69 6C 63 2D 74 6F 6F 6C 6B 69 .1.8 silc-toolki 00000030 74 00 2B 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 t.+diffie-hellma 00000040 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 31 2C 64 69 66 66 69 65 2D n-group1,diffie- 00000050 68 65 6C 6C 6D 61 6E 2D 67 72 6F 75 70 32 00 07 hellman-group2.. 00000060 72 73 61 2C 72 73 61 00 7C 61 65 73 2D 32 35 36 rsa,rsa.|aes-256 00000070 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 74 72 -ctr,aes-192-ctr 00000080 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 74 72 2C 61 65 73 ,aes-128-ctr,aes 00000090 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 39 32 -256-cbc,aes-192 000000A0 2D 63 62 63 2C 61 65 73 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 -cbc,aes-128-cbc 000000B0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 32 35 36 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-256-cbc 000000C0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 39 32 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-192-cbc 000000D0 2C 74 77 6F 66 69 73 68 2D 31 32 38 2D 63 62 63 ,twofish-128-cbc 000000E0 2C 6E 6F 6E 65 00 0F 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 73 68 ,none..sha256,sh 000000F0 61 31 2C 6D 64 35 00 46 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 a1,md5.Fhmac-sha 00000100 32 35 36 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 31 256-96,hmac-sha1 00000110 2D 39 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 2D 39 36 2C -96,hmac-md5-96, 00000120 68 6D 61 63 2D 73 68 61 32 35 36 2C 68 6D 61 63 hmac-sha256,hmac 00000130 2D 73 68 61 31 2C 68 6D 61 63 2D 6D 64 35 00 04 -sha1,hmac-md5.. 00000140 6E 6F 6E 65 00 00 01 50 00 03 72 73 61 00 3F 55 none...P..rsa.?U 00000150 4E 3D 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 48 4E 3D 6E 65 6D 65 N=breed, HN=neme 00000160 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 2C 20 52 4E 3D sis.futurec, RN= 00000170 62 72 65 65 64 2C 20 45 3D 62 72 65 65 64 40 6E breed, E=breed@n 00000180 65 6D 65 73 69 73 2E 66 75 74 75 72 65 63 00 00 emesis.futurec.. 00000190 00 02 FF FD 00 00 01 00 83 5B BB 79 D5 F8 7F 73 .........[.y...s 000001A0 17 BB F1 F4 AE D1 46 22 B2 65 2C 4C AF 3B AA 8A ......F".e,L.;.. 000001B0 28 94 67 17 BC F9 2D 88 22 3E 37 92 B4 78 24 F6 (.g...-.">7..x$. 000001C0 2B 06 92 D8 15 B1 21 12 82 9E C6 E9 24 C4 5B 24 +.....!.....$.[$ 000001D0 77 34 F1 B9 BC B7 BC E6 4C 6D C1 6C 41 76 E5 4E w4......Lm.lAv.N 000001E0 77 51 A9 CB 95 D2 C9 A8 59 1A D8 40 CA 45 AA 3B [email protected].; 000001F0 7F 2B 2F F2 EB C2 23 04 30 37 DE 6E 75 30 D0 FB .+/...#.07.nu0.. 00000200 34 E2 C2 23 DB D6 26 B7 47 40 8D BD 46 83 53 74 4..#..&[email protected] 00000210 46 78 71 5E BE B0 1B 85 C5 27 E8 20 A3 60 D4 3F Fxq^.....'. .`.? 00000220 1A 81 F1 CE 28 06 6C 6E 24 E3 08 39 38 50 BA 9D ....(.ln$..98P.. 00000230 D8 29 8F FD C7 ED 29 BE E4 AF 3C 0B E8 A5 F4 D3 .)....)...<..... 00000240 22 FE 73 34 17 D7 20 C8 3A 87 AF 9D 54 63 B9 C9 ".s4.. .:...Tc.. 00000250 C3 00 CA EA 8E 28 39 E3 4D 5F 70 C7 0E 4A DF 8D .....(9.M_p..J.. 00000260 3C 43 4C A2 A8 02 88 C6 66 32 2B 98 BC AD AB E9 <CL.....f2+..... 00000270 DE 14 FF 88 C6 DB 1F 18 CB 10 AE CE 2F E7 44 4F ............/.DO 00000280 D9 A9 ED 2D 03 F7 CD 0A E9 91 43 D5 BB D0 5A 8B ...-......C...Z. 00000290 15 4F ED 19 97 E6 FD 6D 61 2A 67 9E 03 CB 44 1A .O.....ma*g...D. 000002A0 B6 4B 75 B9 8E E1 2E 9B 61 8B 64 EA 00 27 C9 D0 .Ku.....a.d..'.. 000002B0 77 9F 0F 32 CC 73 7E 98 F1 D8 2B 5C 8E 2A 8E DF w..2.s~...+\.*.. 000002C0 A9 24 78 B8 3D 5B BD A5 F4 37 13 4D F7 3B 9A 82 .$x.=[...7.M.;.. 000002D0 F8 A1 E0 EC 30 F4 CE 09 A7 53 04 43 31 04 60 53 ....0....S.C1.`S 000002E0 CE 40 8D FC E8 72 A7 FF 42 05 F7 69 FF BC 87 2F [email protected].../ 000002F0 1D 9F E3 38 E9 DC 8E 0C 60 65 DA 08 C5 32 D0 C0 ...8....`e...2.. 00000300 0B 71 54 F1 9C B1 24 2D FB 86 AD 44 A7 7B 84 84 .qT...$-...D.{.. 00000310 21 D2 3A 9F 1A 02 33 BF !.:...3. silc_ske_make_hash:778: HASH_i 00000000 7F 70 5F 04 74 67 E6 D4 AD 31 BF EB 2B E8 E5 4B .p_.tg...1..+..K 00000010 30 1A 82 4A 5E C8 68 7D A2 56 4F 40 1C FF 55 3E 0..J^.h}[email protected]> 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_phase4:2143: Verifying signature (HASH_i) [Logging] [Error] Signature verification failed, incorrect signature 09:53:52 silc_ske_st_responder_error:2393: Error 9 (Incorrect signature) during key exchange protocol [Logging] [Error] Error (Incorrect signature) during Key Exchange protocol with 10.0.201.21 (10.0.201.21) 09:53:52 silc_ske_free:1043: Freeing Key Exchange object [Logging] [Info] Closing connection 10.0.201.21:2256 [Unknown] 09:53:52 silc_ske_free:1043: Freeing Key Exchange object