Re: Problem with multiple sites and crossposting

Janne Jalkanen <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.network.sn
Message-ID <[email protected]>
> How are you retrieving the articles?
> Does this indeed save bandwidth?

We have local newsgroups in which we want the posts to be immediately
visible, but since we want the other site to receive them too - we
just synchronize every two hours.

> Since both sites have the same admin, in your position I would
> sync both by having each log in to the other, and issuing sncat -n,
> and feeding that output for snstore; instead of relying on nntp.
> Since bandwidth is an issue, this can be compressed at the source
> and decompressed at the target host.

I'll need to try that.  We are using SSH to both encrypt and compress
the traffic.

> sn wasn't designed to host other sites, so it does not do one
> critical thing: check for loops.  It's not too hard to do this from
> a shell script, basically just make sure any message about to be
> stored does not have self's hostname in the Path: line.

Looking at the path line, it looks something like this:

Path: A|B|A|B|A|B|A|B|A|B|A|B|A|B

I can't claim much expertise in the sources at the moment, so should I
just wrap snstore in a shell script that greps for 'Path' and hostname
and rejects the article?

Though if I understand correctly, that article will then be
transported at each synchronization point anyway, until it expires
(which in our case will mean about a year), getting rejected at the
other end, using bandwidth each time, correct?

-- 
Janne Jalkanen                          Regex Pty Ltd
[email protected]             Level 11
Tel: +61-438 428 041                    530 Lt Collins St
Fax: +61-3-9909 7510                    Melbourne, VIC 3000
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.