An expert on U.S.–Israeli relations reveal s details from his recent visit with the FBI.
Jon S <[email protected]> Fri, 03 Sep 2004 12:20:26 -0700
| Newsgroups | gmane.org.ballistichelmet.heads |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
[ Does anyone think I would be able to get a job with the FBI ? I=20 wonder if background checks into bh would prohibit that. Rooting out=20 this shit seems like it would be a fulfilling job. ] Mole Hunt An expert on U.S.=96Israeli relations reveals details from his recent=20 visit with the FBI. By Jason Vest and Laura Rozen Web Exclusive: 09.03.04 http://www.prospect.org/web/printfriendly-view.ww?id=3D8467 In May, Stephen Green was hard at work campaigning for a seat in=20 Vermont's House of Representatives when he got a phone call. The last=20 person the 64-year-old former United Nations official, then preoccupied=20 with health-care policy issues, expected to hear from was an FBI agent,=20 who asked if he could come to Washington to chat with him about the=20 history of Israeli espionage efforts against the United States. As the author of two books on U.S.-Israeli relations, Green knew=20 something about the subject. Still, the phone call seemed to come out of=20 the blue. Green quickly discovered, however, that the FBI had a keen=20 interest in the subject. Federal agents were involved in an=20 investigation into an alleged Israeli "mole" in the office of Douglas=20 Feith, the under secretary of defense for policy. Early reports suggested that the FBI had wiretap evidence that a veteran=20 Iran analyst working in Feith's office at the Defense Intelligence=20 Agency, Larry Franklin, may have passed a classified draft of a National=20 Security Presidential Directive on Iran to an official working for the=20 pro-Israel lobbying organization, the American Israel Public Affairs=20 Committee (AIPAC). Members of the organization, in turn, were said to=20 have passed the document on to Israel. (AIPAC officials strongly deny=20 the accusations.) But as Green spoke with investigators, he realized the agents were=20 investigating far more than Franklin. "Larry Franklin's name never came up, but several others did," he said. Green, as the FBI agents knew, had a special expertise in the field of=20 Israeli espionage in the United States. In the 1980s, he had taken time=20 off from his job at the UN to look into the U.S.=96Israeli "special=20 relationship." He spent years combing through public records, filing and=20 litigating Freedom of Information Act requests, and tracking down=20 current and retired government officials. He eventually wrote two books,=20 Taking Sides: America's Secret Relations With Israel and Living By The=20 Sword: America and Israel in the Middle East. The Times of London and=20 Foreign Affairs commended his work, describing it as "praised by those=20 who believe the United States has damaged its own security, and Israel's=20 too, by uncritical and often secret support of Israel's actions, no=20 matter how extreme." Yet, as Foreign Affairs reported, Green's work also=20 caused "sputter[ing] with indignation" among "those who believe=85 that=20 American and Israeli interests are identical." Green returned to the UN in 1990 and followed the subject from there.=20 Earlier this year, he published a piece in the newsletter CounterPunch,=20 recapping previously reported -- though long-forgotten -- government=20 investigations of prominent neoconservatives for their suspected=20 espionage or improper information-sharing with Israel. And that's where=20 the FBI comes in. According to the FBI agents who contacted Green, as he recounts, the=20 article had come to their attention when one of Green=92s sources -- a=20 retired national security official they were interviewing -- shared it=20 with them. And so on June 22, Green found himself sitting across an oval-shaped=20 conference table from two FBI agents at an undisclosed northern Virginia=20 venue. The meeting lasted nearly four hours. "They were extraordinarily well-informed; it was apparent they've been=20 at this for awhile," Green says. "I asked them if there was a current=20 reason for them asking questions about things that go back over 30=20 years, and they sort of looked at each other and said, 'Yes, it's a=20 present issue,' but wouldn't say specifically what. Though they did ask=20 very specific questions about one individual in particular." Green said the agents asked about several current or former Pentagon=20 officials such as Paul Wolfowitz, Richard Perle, Douglas Feith, Michael=20 Ledeen, and Stephen Bryen. "The tenor of their questions was such that it defined where these=20 people were in terms of the nature of their focus," Green says. "They=20 also asked about a couple other Office of Special Plans people,=20 including Harold Rhode. Ironically, about the only name that didn't come=20 up was Larry Franklin." Regardless of the status of the investigation, something seemed a bit=20 fishy. After all, Israel -- one of the United States=92 closest allies,=20 with deep support in the Bush Administration and especially at the=20 Defense Department -- hardly needs a Pentagon-embedded spy to get access=20 to interagency debates about U.S. policy to Iran, as observers have=20 pointed out. And compared with the information on arms shipments that=20 former US Navy analyst Jonathan Pollard passed on to Israel in the=20 1980s, a draft of a document about U.S. policy toward Iran would hardly=20 seem like the crown jewels. Yet, as Newsweek has reported, Franklin had come to the FBI=92s attention= =20 a year and a half ago, when he walked in on a lunch with an Israeli=20 diplomat and an AIPAC lobbyist, both of whom were under FBI surveillance=20 for a year. In addition, Newsweek reported that when news of the=20 investigation surfaced, Franklin had already been cooperating with the=20 FBI for several weeks and had reportedly led FBI agents to those who may=20 have received information from him. The previous FBI investigation came into focus only on September 1, when=20 The Washington Post reported that for two years, the FBI has conducted a=20 counterintelligence investigation into whether AIPAC has forwarded=20 =93highly classified materials from the National Security Agency . . . to= =20 Israel.=94 The Post piece describes Franklin=92s alleged role as merely=20 =93coincidental=94 to the larger FBI probe of alleged intelligence-passin= g=20 through AIPAC to Israel. Both AIPAC and Tel Aviv vehemently deny any wrongdoing. And indeed, the=20 Israeli diplomat who acknowledges meeting with Franklin and AIPAC --=20 Naor Gilon, the Israeli embassy=92s No. 3 official and a specialist on=20 Iran=92s nuclear program -- returned to Washington on August 29 from a=20 summer vacation in Israel. He admits that he met with Franklin, but=20 insists he=92s done nothing wrong. A source familiar with the investigation told The American Prospect that=20 when news of the investigation broke, the Justice Department had been=20 preparing a request to the State Department to have an Israeli diplomat=20 -- by implication Gilon -- declared persona non grata for allegedly=20 having received classified U.S. intelligence from AIPAC sources. Furthermore, a September 1 report by NBC speculated that the reason the=20 Israelis may have broken their declared post-Pollard policy of not=20 spying on the United States is because of Israel=92s preeminent concern=20 about Iran=92s nuclear program, and its view that the United States may=20 not be prepared to act assertively enough to prevent Iran from acquiring=20 nuclear weapons. The Post piece seems to imply that Franklin is more of an anti-Tehran=20 zealot than anything else and wasn=92t engaging in espionage per se. But=20 as the Post article and the June meeting between Green and the FBI seem=20 to indicate, the FBI is looking into the possibility there's been=20 communication between Israeli elements and U.S. officials, including=20 several who work for Feith and have access to sensitive intelligence on=20 Iran and its nuclear program. Jason Vest is Prospect senior correspondent. Laura Rozen reports on=20 national security issues from Washington, D.C. and for her weblog, War=20 and Piece. _______________________________________________ heads mailing list [email protected] http://your.ballistichelmet.org/mailman/listinfo/heads/ http://ballistichelmet.org/donate/