Re: KHADAS EDGE V booting hangs if I install UEFI instead of u-boot

Mark Millard <[email protected]> Thu, 7 Aug 2025 22:13:57 -0700
Newsgroups	gmane.os.freebsd.devel.arm
Message-ID	<[email protected]>
On Aug 7, 2025, at 17:20, Mario Marietto <[email protected]> wrote:

> On FreeBSD 13.0 for the KHADAS :
> 
> root@khadas-edge:~ # gpart show                                                                          
> 
> =>       40  249737136  mmcsd0  GPT  (119G)                                                              
>          40      32728          - free -  (16M)                                                          
>       32768     102400       1  efi  (50M)                                                               
>      135168     524288       2  freebsd-swap  (256M)                                                     
>      659456  249073664       3  freebsd-ufs  (119G)                                                      
>   249733120       4056          - free -  (2.0M)                                                         
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293  mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                       
>         34     16350          - free -  (8.0M)                                                           
>      16384      8192       1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)                              
>      24576      8192       2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)                              
>      32768      8192       3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)                              
>      40960      8192       4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)                              
>      49152      8192       5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)                              
>      57344      2048       6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)                              
>      59392     65536       7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)                               
>     124928      8192       8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)                              
>     133120    196608       9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)                               
>     329728    229376      10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)                              
>     559104    786432      11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)                              
>    1345536     32768      12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)                               
>    1378304      1024      13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)                              
>    1379328   6373376      14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)                              
>    7752704  53318623      15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G). . .

[For the above, see later where naming is clearer.]

> root@khadas-edge:~ # gpart show -p                                                                       
> =>       40  249737136    mmcsd0  GPT  (119G)                                                            
>          40      32728            - free -  (16M)                                                        
>       32768     102400  mmcsd0p1  efi  (50M)                                                             
>      135168     524288  mmcsd0p2  freebsd-swap  (256M)                                                   
>      659456  249073664  mmcsd0p3  freebsd-ufs  (119G)                                                    
>   249733120       4056            - free -  (2.0M)                                                       
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293     mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                    
>         34     16350             - free -  (8.0M)                                                        
>      16384      8192   mmcsd1p1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)                           
>      24576      8192   mmcsd1p2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)                           
>      32768      8192   mmcsd1p3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)                           
>      40960      8192   mmcsd1p4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)                           
>      49152      8192   mmcsd1p5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)                           
>      57344      2048   mmcsd1p6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)                           
>      59392     65536   mmcsd1p7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)                            
>     124928      8192   mmcsd1p8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)                           
>     133120    196608   mmcsd1p9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)                            
>     329728    229376  mmcsd1p10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)                           
>     559104    786432  mmcsd1p11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)                           
>    1345536     32768  mmcsd1p12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)                            
>    1378304      1024  mmcsd1p13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)                           
>    1379328   6373376  mmcsd1p14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)                           
>    7752704  53318623  mmcsd1p15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G)

[For the above, see later where naming is clearer.]

> root@khadas-edge:~ # gpart show -pl                                                                      
> =>       40  249737136    mmcsd0  GPT  (119G)                                                            
>          40      32728            - free -  (16M)                                                        
>       32768     102400  mmcsd0p1  efi  (50M)                                                             
>      135168     524288  mmcsd0p2  swapfs  (256M)                                                         
>      659456  249073664  mmcsd0p3  install  (119G)                                                        
>   249733120       4056            - free -  (2.0M)                                                       
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293     mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                    
>         34     16350             - free -  (8.0M)                                                        
>      16384      8192   mmcsd1p1  uboot  (4.0M)                                                           
>      24576      8192   mmcsd1p2  trust  (4.0M)                                                           
>      32768      8192   mmcsd1p3  misc  (4.0M)                                                            
>      40960      8192   mmcsd1p4  dtb  (4.0M)                                                             
>      49152      8192   mmcsd1p5  dtbo  (4.0M)                                                            
>      57344      2048   mmcsd1p6  vbmeta  (1.0M)                                                          
>      59392     65536   mmcsd1p7  boot  (32M)                                                             
>     124928      8192   mmcsd1p8  security  (4.0M)                                                        
>     133120    196608   mmcsd1p9  recovery  (96M)                                                         
>     329728    229376  mmcsd1p10  backup  (112M)                                                          
>     559104    786432  mmcsd1p11  cache  (384M)                                                           
>    1345536     32768  mmcsd1p12  metadata  (16M)                                                         
>    1378304      1024  mmcsd1p13  frp  (512K)                                                             
>    1379328   6373376  mmcsd1p14  super  (3.0G)                                                           
>    7752704  53318623  mmcsd1p15  userdata  (25G)

Well, the above for /dev/mmcsd1 (the eMMC) is very
interesting. It indicates another place that a
uboot and other things might be found and used,
independent of the microsd card in the slot.

The [CORRUPT] note suggests that the "GPT 0x3190d20
signature is wrong" might be about /dev/mmcsd1
instead of the microsd card in the slot. That would,
in turn, suggest that the "Load uboot, ReadLba = 2000"
and "Load OK, addr=0x200000, size=0xf0000" might also
be from/for activity using /dev/mmcsd1 .

But I do not know.

Does the system appear to do any initial boot
activity when there is no microsd card in the slot?
Does it still report those kinds of messages?

> root@khadas-edge:~ # df -m                          
>                                                      
> Filesystem       1M-blocks  Used Avail Capacity  Mounted on                                              
> /dev/gpt/install    117778 50625 57731    47%    /                                                       
> devfs                    0     0     0   100%    /dev                                                    
> fdescfs                  0     0     0   100%    /dev/fd                                                 
> procfs                   0     0     0   100%    /proc                                                   
> /dev/md0                61     0    56     0%    /var/log                                                
> tmpfs                 1024     0  1023     0%    /tmp
> 
> FreeBSD 14.2 for RockPro64 running on KHADAS (with the panfrost enabled) : the same image as before :
> 
> root@Rock:~ # gpart show                                                                                 
> =>       40  384503735  mmcsd0  GPT  (183G)                                                              
>          40      32728          - free -  (16M)                                                          
>       32768     102400       1  efi  (50M)                                                               
>      135168  368209920       2  freebsd-ufs  (176G)                                                      
>   368345088   16154624       3  freebsd-swap  (7.7G)                                                     
>   384499712       4063          - free -  (2.0M)                                                         
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293  mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                       
>         34     16350          - free -  (8.0M)                                                           
>      16384      8192       1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)                              
>      24576      8192       2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)                              
>      32768      8192       3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)                              
>      40960      8192       4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)                              
>      49152      8192       5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)                              
>      57344      2048       6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)                              
>      59392     65536       7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)                               
>     124928      8192       8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)                              
>     133120    196608       9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)                               
>     329728    229376      10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)                              
>     559104    786432      11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)                              
>    1345536     32768      12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)                               
>    1378304      1024      13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)                              
>    1379328   6373376      14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)                              
>    7752704  53318623      15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G)                              

[For the above, see later where naming is clearer.]
                                                                                                         
> =>      34  61071293  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                         
>         34     16350                        - free -  (8.0M)                                             
>      16384      8192                     1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)                
>      24576      8192                     2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)                
>      32768      8192                     3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)                
>      40960      8192                     4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)                
>      49152      8192                     5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)                
>      57344      2048                     6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)                
>      59392     65536                     7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)                 
>     124928      8192                     8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)                
>     133120    196608                     9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)                 
>     329728    229376                    10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)                
>     559104    786432                    11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)                
>    1345536     32768                    12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)                 
>    1378304      1024                    13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)                
>    1379328   6373376                    14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)                
>    7752704  53318623                    15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G)

[For the above, see later where naming is clearer.]

> root@Rock:~ # gpart show -p                                                                              
> =>       40  384503735    mmcsd0  GPT  (183G)                                                            
>          40      32728            - free -  (16M)                                                        
>       32768     102400  mmcsd0p1  efi  (50M)                                                             
>      135168  368209920  mmcsd0p2  freebsd-ufs  (176G)                                                    
>   368345088   16154624  mmcsd0p3  freebsd-swap  (7.7G)                                                   
>   384499712       4063            - free -  (2.0M)                                                       
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293     mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                    
>         34     16350             - free -  (8.0M)                                                        
>      16384      8192   mmcsd1p1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)                           
>      24576      8192   mmcsd1p2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)                           
>      32768      8192   mmcsd1p3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)                           
>      40960      8192   mmcsd1p4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)                           
>      49152      8192   mmcsd1p5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)                           
>      57344      2048   mmcsd1p6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)                           
>      59392     65536   mmcsd1p7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)                            
>     124928      8192   mmcsd1p8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)                           
>     133120    196608   mmcsd1p9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)                            
>     329728    229376  mmcsd1p10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)                           
>     559104    786432  mmcsd1p11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)                           
>    1345536     32768  mmcsd1p12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)                            
>    1378304      1024  mmcsd1p13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)                           
>    1379328   6373376  mmcsd1p14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)                           
>    7752704  53318623  mmcsd1p15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G)                            

[See later where naming is clearer.]
                                                                                                         
> =>      34  61071293     diskid/DISK-F84B4A79  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                      
>         34     16350                           - free -  (8.0M)                                          
>      16384      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p1  !d3370000-0000-442a-8000-354200006eec  (4.0M)             
>      24576      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p2  !8a760000-0000-415c-8000-5d7c000009ab  (4.0M)             
>      32768      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p3  !1a7e0000-0000-446f-8000-4ff800003479  (4.0M)             
>      40960      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p4  !aa780000-0000-4420-8000-68df000072ff  (4.0M)             
>      49152      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p5  !63200000-0000-4a03-8000-195800001ce4  (4.0M)             
>      57344      2048   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p6  !6d470000-0000-4e7e-8000-688c00005cd1  (1.0M)             
>      59392     65536   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p7  !ef500000-0000-474c-8000-6ea20000346e  (32M)              
>     124928      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p8  !11340000-0000-4d7b-8000-57c300007662  (4.0M)             
>     133120    196608   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p9  !fd7f0000-0000-4970-8000-661700004a56  (96M)              
>     329728    229376  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p10  !d8510000-0000-4360-8000-70c500002df1  (112M)             
>     559104    786432  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p11  !cd600000-0000-4255-8000-5df600006edc  (384M)             
>    1345536     32768  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p12  !01720000-0000-4f30-8000-2cd1000030be  (16M)              
>    1378304      1024  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p13  !9f640000-0000-4123-8000-6d7f00006c40  (512K)             
>    1379328   6373376  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p14  !cd270000-0000-4134-8000-462700006e0a  (3.0G)             
>    7752704  53318623  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p15  !b33f0000-0000-463e-8000-6ff2000054c3  (25G)

[See later where naming is clearer.]

> root@Rock:~ # gpart show -pl                                                                             
> =>       40  384503735    mmcsd0  GPT  (183G)                                                            
>          40      32728            - free -  (16M)                                                        
>       32768     102400  mmcsd0p1  efi  (50M)                                                             
>      135168  368209920  mmcsd0p2  rootfs  (176G)                                                         
>   368345088   16154624  mmcsd0p3  (null)  (7.7G)                                                         
>   384499712       4063            - free -  (2.0M)                                                       
>                                                                                                          
> =>      34  61071293     mmcsd1  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                                    
>         34     16350             - free -  (8.0M)                                                        
>      16384      8192   mmcsd1p1  uboot  (4.0M)                                                           
>      24576      8192   mmcsd1p2  trust  (4.0M)                                                           
>      32768      8192   mmcsd1p3  misc  (4.0M)                                                            
>      40960      8192   mmcsd1p4  dtb  (4.0M)                                                             
>      49152      8192   mmcsd1p5  dtbo  (4.0M)                                                            
>      57344      2048   mmcsd1p6  vbmeta  (1.0M)                                                          
>      59392     65536   mmcsd1p7  boot  (32M)                                                             
>     124928      8192   mmcsd1p8  security  (4.0M)                                                        
>     133120    196608   mmcsd1p9  recovery  (96M)                                                         
>     329728    229376  mmcsd1p10  backup  (112M)                                                          
>     559104    786432  mmcsd1p11  cache  (384M)                                                           
>    1345536     32768  mmcsd1p12  metadata  (16M)                                                         
>    1378304      1024  mmcsd1p13  frp  (512K)                                                             
>    1379328   6373376  mmcsd1p14  super  (3.0G)                                                          
>    7752704  53318623  mmcsd1p15  userdata  (25G)


The above is the same /dev/mmcsd1 (eMMC).

> =>      34  61071293     diskid/DISK-F84B4A79  GPT  (29G) [CORRUPT]                                      
>         34     16350                           - free -  (8.0M)                                          
>      16384      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p1  uboot  (4.0M)                                             
>      24576      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p2  trust  (4.0M)                                             
>      32768      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p3  misc  (4.0M)                                              
>      40960      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p4  dtb  (4.0M)                                               
>      49152      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p5  dtbo  (4.0M)                                              
>      57344      2048   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p6  vbmeta  (1.0M)                                            
>      59392     65536   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p7  boot  (32M)                                               
>     124928      8192   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p8  security  (4.0M)                                          
>     133120    196608   diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p9  recovery  (96M)                                           
>     329728    229376  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p10  backup  (112M)                                            
>     559104    786432  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p11  cache  (384M)                                             
>    1345536     32768  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p12  metadata  (16M)                                           
>    1378304      1024  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p13  frp  (512K)                                               
>    1379328   6373376  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p14  super  (3.0G)                                             
>    7752704  53318623  diskid/DISK-F84B4A79p15  userdata  (25G)

The above is the same /dev/mmcsd1 (eMMC).

> root@Rock:~ # df -m                                                                                      
> 
> Filesystem       1M-blocks  Used  Avail Capacity  Mounted on                                             
> /dev/ufs/rootfs     174137 24879 135327    16%    /                                                      
> devfs                    0     0      0     0%    /dev                                                   
> /dev/msdosfs/EFI        49     3     46     6%    /boot/efi                                              
> tmpfs                11538     0  11538     0%    /tmp 
> 
> 
> On Thu, Aug 7, 2025 at 9:01 PM Mark Millard <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> 
> On Aug 7, 2025, at 09:27, Mario Marietto <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> > . . .                                 
> > FreeBSD 14.2-RELEASE-p1 GENERIC arm64                                                                
> > . . .                                                      
> > GEOM: mmcsd1: the primary GPT table is corrupt or invalid.                                           
> > GEOM: mmcsd1: using the secondary instead -- recovery strongly advised.                              
> > GEOM: diskid/DISK-F84B4A79: the primary GPT table is corrupt or invalid.                             
> > GEOM: diskid/DISK-F84B4A79: using the secondary instead -- recovery strongly advised.                
> 
> Given the above . . .
> 
> When booted via FreeBSD 13.0 , what do the following
> commands show?
> 
> # gpart show
> . . .
> # gpart show -p
> . . .
> # gpart show -pl
> . . .
> # df -m
> . . .
> 
> Possibly: also for 14.2 .
> 
> 
> > Dual Console: Video Primary, Serial Secondary
> 
> I've suggested adjusting /boot/loader.conf
> to just have Serial enabled for now:
> 
> boot_multicons="NO"
> boot_serial="YES"
> 
> >  . . .
> > > FreeBSD 13.0-RELEASE-p1 #0: Sun Jun 13 17:07:42 MSK 2021                                             
> > . . .                                
> > > Trying to mount root from ufs:/dev/gpt/install [rw,noatime]...                                       
> > > GEOM: mmcsd1: the primary GPT table is corrupt or invalid.                                           
> > > uhub4: 2 ports with 2 removable, self powered                                                        
> > > GEOM: mmcsd1: using the secondary instead -- recovery strongly advised.                              
> > > uhub2: 1 port with 1 removable, self powered                                                         
> > > Dual Console: Serial Primary, Video Secondary                                                        
> > > . . .



===
Mark Millard
marklmi at yahoo.com