Re: ral/wpa_supplicant drops after successful WPA negotiation?

This is follow-up to
http://docs.FreeBSD.org/cgi/mid.cgi?43FA61A4.8030406 (lengthy!)

In short, I am trying to use WPA with the ral driver (ral0: MAC/BBP
RT2560 (rev 0x04), RF RT2525) on 6.0 RELEASE.  wpa_supplicant seems to
negotiate successfully but then times out (authentication time-out).
The debug message is "ral0: [XX:XX:XX:XX:XX:XX] send station
disassociate (reason 8)"
I also get an error "ioctl[SIOCS80211, op 20, len 7]: Can't assign
requested address".

Sam gave a suggestion as to the cause:
> This sort of looks like the race I fixed in HEAD recently that caused
> the timer used to identify unanswered mgt frame transmits to trigger
> unexpectedly.
but further digging showed it wasn't (symptoms didn't match).

Well, I now can add more info: using Kismet from a separate PC I find
one instance where the authentication times out *after* sending an
encrypted data package.  It's acknowledged (and then further ignored,
since it's IPv6) by the AP.  See frame 252 below.  I can provide full
details if useful.
Disabling IPv6 does make no difference (auth time-out) so I would
guess that it's not related to that.

Excerpt from text export of kismet dump (belkin is the FreeBSD host,
D-Link is the AP; I deleted all beacons and packets from other APs and
hosts):
============================================================
No.     Time        Source                Destination           Protocol Info
    207 84.392377   Belkin_14:e8:0a       Broadcast             Probe
Request Probe Request,SN=1,FN=0, SSID: Broadcast
    208 84.392790                         D-Link_1a:0b:65 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    209 84.393472   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Probe
Response Probe Response,SN=186,FN=0,BI=1000, SSID: "Epsilon3"
    210 84.393591                         D-Link_05:1e:32 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    219 86.993477   Belkin_14:e8:0a       D-Link_05:1e:32      
Authentication Authentication,SN=0,FN=0
    220 86.993651                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    221 86.994076   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a      
Authentication Authentication,SN=195,FN=0
    222 86.994624   Belkin_14:e8:0a       D-Link_05:1e:32      
Association Request Association Request,SN=1,FN=0, SSID: "Epsilon3"
    223 86.994791                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    224 86.995288   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a      
Authentication Authentication,SN=195,FN=0
    225 86.995409                         D-Link_05:1e:32 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    226 86.996484   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a      
Association Response Association Response,SN=196,FN=0
    227 86.996964   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a      
Association Response Association Response,SN=196,FN=0
    228 86.997088                         D-Link_05:1e:32 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    232 88.270387   fe80::211:50ff:fe14:e80a ff02::2:4c46:3d12    
ICMPv6   Multicast listener report
    233 88.270620                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    236 90.473873   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       EAPOL    Key
    237 90.474098                         D-Link_05:1e:32 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    238 90.474716   Belkin_14:e8:0a       D-Link_05:1e:32       EAPOL    Key
    239 90.474951                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    240 90.477506   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       EAPOL    Key
    241 90.477735                         D-Link_05:1e:32 (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    242 90.478066   Belkin_14:e8:0a       D-Link_05:1e:32       EAPOL    Key
    243 90.478301                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    244 90.480196   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Data  
  Data,SN=204,FN=0
    245 90.480814   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Data  
  Data,SN=204,FN=0
    246 90.481250   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Data  
  Data,SN=204,FN=0
    247 90.482007   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Data  
  Data,SN=204,FN=0
    248 90.482705   D-Link_05:1e:32       Belkin_14:e8:0a       Data  
  Data,SN=204,FN=0
    252 93.470464   Belkin_14:e8:0a      
IPv6-Neighbor-Discovery_ff:14:e8:0a Data     Data,SN=5,FN=0
    253 93.470688                         Belkin_14:e8:0a (RA) 
Acknowledgement Acknowledgement
    254 93.471615   Belkin_14:e8:0a      
IPv6-Neighbor-Discovery_ff:14:e8:0a Data     Data,SN=208,FN=0
    281 118.677849  Belkin_14:e8:0a       Broadcast             Probe
Request Probe Request,SN=41,FN=0, SSID: Broadcast
============================================================
Frames 244-248 are resends of the same encrypted data by the AP.

Any suggestion what to do next?
- buy a new wlan card?
- buy a new AP?
- install driver or kernel upgrade?
- install Sam's bug fix even though it doesn't match the symptoms?
- do something else that might help pinpoint the issue?

(& don't hesitate to tell me I should post this elsewhere!)

Cheers, Peter
_______________________________________________
[email protected] mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-mobile
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "[email protected]"