Re: Suspend problem on FreeBSD 5.3-STABLE

On Wed, Jan 12, 2005 at 07:29:48AM -0700, M. Warner Losh wrote:
> : > FA411 16 bit PCMCIA card after a suspend/resume works as expected. I 
> : > will try to down the interface and kldunload the dc driver before 
> : > shutdown to see if that helps.
> : 
> : That fits with my analysis as well.  It seems that cardbus handles 
> : things fine but individual drivers may be lacking in suspend/resume support.
> 
> Cardbus should be detaching and reattaching the device.  So that's
> clearly a bug in cardbus.  Individual drivers have no choice in this
> matter, since we can't know if the cards that are there after the
> resume were the ones we suspended with.  This doesn't matter too much
> for NIC cards (but none of the drivers cope with MAC addresses
> changing), but matters a great deal for things like flash cards.
> 
> : That's a good testing approach, btw.  If you find the dc(4) driver seems 
> : to be the culprit, the next step is to go through any datasheets and 
> : other OS drivers to see if you can find what we're doing differently.
> 
> I don't think that it is a dc problem.
> 

After my tests I'm not sure where it is. Here's what I did:

   o Compiled a kernel without dc support so I could 

     # kldload if_dc

   o Loaded if_dc.ko as a module
   o Inserted the card
     
At this time the card was properly probed.

   o Ran dhclient dc0 and observed the card get an ip address from
     my dhcp server.
   o Did some more network tests (hit http://www.ebay.com in
     firefox...)
   o Turned off the card nicely prior to detaching it:

     # ifconfig dc0 down delete

   o Unplugged the card and observed it detach from the cbb0
     "slot".
   o Unloaded the if_dc driver:

     # kldunload if_dc

   o Suspend the laptop to standby mode:

     # sysctl hw.acpi.lid_switch_state="S3"

     Close the laptop's lid

   o Resume:

     Open the laptop's lid

   o Reload the driver (kldload if_dc...)
   o Pluggin the card

At this time the cardbus driver reports:

     "cbb0: CardBus card activation failed"

This leads me to believe that either the CardBus handler has a problem
attaching an existing "used" dc driver to the card after a
suspend/resume or the dc driver has left something in a state after
it's detach where a re-attach will not work correctly.

Has anyone got any other ideas?

-- Chris




-- 
-- 
Chris Hilton                                 chilton-at-vindaloo-dot-com
------------------------------------------------------------------------
                "All I was doing was trying to get home from work!"
                                                 -- Rosa Parks