Re: kern/60457: Hang during shutdown/reboot (with zfs root with failed component)

The following reply was made to PR kern/60457; it has been noted by GNATS.

From: Andrius V <[email protected]>
To: [email protected]
Cc: [email protected], [email protected]
Subject: Re: kern/60457: Hang during shutdown/reboot (with zfs root with
 failed component)
Date: Sat, 18 Jul 2026 14:18:21 +0300

 On Fri, Jul 17, 2026 at 10:55=E2=80=AFPM [email protected] via gnats
 <[email protected]> wrote:
 >
 > >Number:         60457
 > >Category:       kern
 > >Synopsis:       Hang during shutdown/reboot (with zfs root with failed c=
 omponent)
 > >Confidential:   no
 > >Severity:       serious
 > >Priority:       high
 > >Responsible:    kern-bug-people
 > >State:          open
 > >Class:          sw-bug
 > >Submitter-Id:   net
 > >Arrival-Date:   Fri Jul 17 19:55:00 +0000 2026
 > >Originator:     Jeff Rizzo
 > >Release:        11.0_RC6
 > >Organization:
 > >Environment:
 > NetBSD cherimoya.tastylime.net 11.0_RC6 NetBSD 11.0_RC6 (GENERIC) #6: Fri=
  Jul 17 18:46:30 UTC 2026  [email protected]:/tank/netbsd/netbsd-11/ob=
 j/sys/arch/amd64/compile/GENERIC amd64
 > >Description:
 > This machine consistently gets stuck sometime _after_ hw.cnmagic is effec=
 tive (I can't get into ddb) and _before_ everything is undone for shutdown,=
  and it will indefinitely (for at least an hour, anyway) hang:
 >
 >
 > Jul 17 18:56:59 [ 156.7362082] syncing disks... done
 > [ 214.3661561] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN6_OUTLET'
 > [ 214.4161559] dk11 at sd2 (c3440c02-2fec-11f1-8000-000000000000) deleted
 > [ 214.4261558] dk10 at sd2 (c3440c01-2fec-11f1-8000-000000000000) deleted
 > [ 214.4261558] sd2: detached
 > [ 214.4361555] sd1: detached
 > [ 214.4361555] dk1 at sd0 (NBImgRoot) deleted
 > [ 214.4361555] dk0 at sd0 (EFI system) deleted
 > [ 214.4461557] sd0: detached
 > [ 214.4461557] scsibus2: detached
 > [ 214.4461557] scsibus1: detached
 > [ 214.4561557] scsibus0: detached
 > [ 214.4561557] dk7 at wd2 (zfs-rpool-wd2) deleted
 > [ 214.4661550] dk6 at wd2 (rf-component-wd2) deleted
 > [ 214.4661550] wd2: detached
 > [ 214.4661550] uhub5: detached
 > [ 214.4761557] uhub4: detached
 > [ 214.4761557] uhub3: detached
 > [ 214.4761557] uhub2: detached
 > [ 214.4861557] uhub0: detached
 > [ 214.4861557] igphy1: detached
 > lagg0: [ 214.4861557] disable distributing on wm1
 > [ 244.3661277] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN6_INLET'
 > [ 244.3761278] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN5_OUTLET'
 > [ 244.3761278] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN5_INLET'
 > [ 1354.3650987] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN4_OUTLET'
 > [ 1354.3750988] ipmi0: normal state on 'FAN3_OUTLET'
 > [ 1894.3645934] ipmi0: critical under limit on 'FAN4_OUTLET'
 > [ 1894.3745935] ipmi0: critical under limit on 'FAN3_OUTLET'
 >
 > ...the messages from ipmi0 continue, but no more disks detach.
 >
 > I have other machines with zfs root which don't exhibit this problem, but=
  this machine currently has a failed component (and working systems don't h=
 ave failed components):
 >
 >         NAME                      STATE     READ WRITE CKSUM
 >         rpool                     DEGRADED     0     0     0
 >           raidz2-0                DEGRADED     0     0     0
 >             dk3                   ONLINE       0     0     0
 >             dk5                   ONLINE       0     0     0
 >             13185259948679916708  OFFLINE      0     0     0  was /dev/dk=
 7
 >             dk9                   ONLINE       0     0     0
 >
 > Here's what disks look like after a boot:
 >
 > [     5.387244] dk0 at sd0: "EFI system", 262144 blocks at 2048, type: ms=
 dos
 > [     5.403522] dk1 at sd0: "NBImgRoot", 976502784 blocks at 264192, type=
 : ffs
 > [     5.696224] dk2 at wd0: "rf-component-wd0", 4194304 blocks at 128, ty=
 pe: raidframe
 > [     5.713521] dk3 at wd0: "zfs-rpool-wd0", 31247564632 blocks at 419443=
 2, type: zfs
 > [     5.835644] dk4 at wd1: "rf-component-wd1", 4194304 blocks at 128, ty=
 pe: raidframe
 > [     5.844158] dk5 at wd1: "zfs-rpool-wd1", 31247564632 blocks at 419443=
 2, type: zfs
 > [     5.963521] dk6 at wd2: "rf-component-wd2", 4194304 blocks at 128, ty=
 pe: raidframe
 > [     5.973521] dk7 at wd2: "zfs-rpool-wd2", 31247564632 blocks at 419443=
 2, type: zfs
 > [     6.093521] dk8 at wd3: "cherimoya-swap-wd3", 4194304 blocks at 128, =
 type: swap
 > [     6.103521] dk9 at wd3: "zfs-rpool-wd3", 31247564632 blocks at 419443=
 2, type: zfs
 > [     7.627989] dk10 at sd2: "c3440c01-2fec-11f1-8000-000000000000", 2621=
 44 blocks at 2048, type: msdos
 > [     7.653664] dk11 at sd2: "c3440c02-2fec-11f1-8000-000000000000", 4853=
 760 blocks at 264192, type: ffs
 > [     8.203517] raid0: Components: /dev/dk2 /dev/dk4
 >
 > (wd2 has a ton of errors and is currently awaiting replacement)
 >
 > I'd love suggestions on more troubleshooting steps - I can't get into DDB=
  at the point of hang; I could sprinkle debugging printfs but so
 > far they've just told me that x86_reset() isn't reached...
 > >How-To-Repeat:
 > boot 11.0_RC6 with zfs root as described in the netbsd wiki (pivot root)
 >
 > shutdown -r now
 >
 > get as far as detaching some-but-not-all dk(4) devices
 >
 > wait indefinitely for IPMI power reset to finish reboot
 > >Fix:
 > none given
 >
 
 Hi,
 
 Since, I see lagg(4) in the logs, I think it may cause hang, not zfs.
 I have a similar problem on my NAS system. If it is not being brought
 down first, shutdown or reboot hangs, I've just never filed a bug
 report for that.
 If you have this option, try to bring down lagg with ifconfig lagg0
 down and reboot.
 
 Regards,
 Andrius V