Re: NetBSD on Edimax BR6104K - Stability

Hi,

>> What is missing with respect to the ethernet switch (except an userland
>> interface for configuring the VLANs)? It is running and VLAN
>> configuration can successfully be changed by editing if_admsw.c. Okay,
>> that is not really comfortable but it works perfectly on my unit.
> 
> I would like for bridge(4) & admsw(4) to cooperate to provide the
> VLAN function.  I.e., if you create bridge0 and 'brconfig bridge0 add
> admsw0 add admsw1', then admsw0 and admsw1 should add themselves to the
> same VLAN.  In this way, the h/w optimization is transparent to the user,
> who does not have to learn Yet Another Tool to setup networking. :-)

Okay. So far I just used the switch as configurable switch and dropped
all kind of software bridges - so I just played with the switch matrix
in order to have just admsw0 connected to all 5 ports of the router. But
 right, the used needs more than this.

>> NAND flash would be really great especially since there is a lot of
>> space left. The BR6104K has 2 MB flash and my nfs-image is (gzip'ed)
>> only 539K small. I guess switching from NFS code to flash would not
>> really increase that so 1,5 MB should be left. That is much more than
>> OpenWRT leaves - they have some 400 or 500 KB left and can run a busybox
>> + uclibc based userland out of this.
> 
> Wow, that is really small.  What is on your NFS image?

Just the bare minimum for the kernel (okay... I could also drop PROCFS):

include 	"arch/evbmips/conf/std.adm5120"

#ident 		"GENERIC-$Revision: 1.2 $"

maxusers	32

options 	MIPS32
options 	NOFPU		# No FPU
options 	SOFTFLOAT	# emulate FPU insn
options		CONSPEED=115200	# YAMON default
options 	HZ=512		# for profiling (512)

options 	SOSEND_LOAN
options 	SOSEND_COUNTERS
options 	INET_CSUM_COUNTERS
options 	TCP_CSUM_COUNTERS
options 	UDP_CSUM_COUNTERS
options 	TCP_OUTPUT_COUNTERS

makeoptions 	CPUFLAGS="-march=4kc"	# compile full symbol table

options         KERNEL_ENTRY_OFFSET=0x6d8  # For the Edimax bootloader
options         MEMORY_RBFLAGS=0        # Don't force single user

file-system	NFS		# Sun NFS-compatible filesystem client
file-system	PROCFS		# /proc

options 	INET		# Internet protocols

options 	NFS_BOOT_DHCP

config		netbsd-admsw0	root on admsw0 type nfs

mainbus0 	at root

cpu0 		at mainbus?

pseudo-device	loop				# network loopback
pseudo-device	pty				# pseudo-terminals
pseudo-device	rnd				# /dev/random & kernel generator

pseudo-device	ksyms

obio*		at mainbus?
gpio*		at mainbus?
extio*		at mainbus?

uart*		at obio? addr ?
admsw*		at obio? addr ?

options       MSGBUFSIZE=65536

This compiles into 539 KB of gzip'ed kernel.

The userland on the server is obviously much bigger - I just used an
untar'ed evbmips userland from 4.0 which is something around 200 MB.
Another 200 MB are configured as swap - this is really needed although
it is very slow but with 16 MB RAM swap is essential for nearly
everything (especially compiling).

Greetings,

Jan

   ------------------------------------------------------------------
  / Dr. Jan Richling - http://www.richling.de                      /
 / Member of Computer Architecture and Communication Group -      /
/ Department of Computer Science - Humboldt University Berlin    /