His own people!
Paul Ford <ford-1TlsmxKV/[email protected]> Sat, 22 Feb 2003 00:16:40 -0500
| Newsgroups | gmane.politics.leftists.monkeyfist |
|---|---|
| Organization | Ftrain |
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
My pal Jim Esch threw this up on his weblog at http://www.turksheadreview.com/ - it's a brief and interesting exploration of some of the rhetoric of the push for war in Iraq. -pef http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=%22his+own+people%22 A few months back, we observed the semantic abuse of the phrase "there's no doubt" in the government and mass media, in reference to Saddam Hussein's possession of weapons of mass destruction -- an ominiscient, panoptic knowledge revealed before UN inspectors returned to Iraqi soil to see for themselves. Now the semantic building block making the rounds is the catchy "his own people." Usually you hear this in reference to Saddam "gassing his own people," but if you do a Google news search on the truncated "his own people," you will find more structuralist magic at work (over 1500 news articles at last count). The verbs conjoined to "his own people" are varied: he murders his own people, starves his own people, is cruel to his own people, treats his own people badly, has diabolical plans against his own people, tortures his own people. Apparently, "his own people" has rhetorical utility. Why? The people are Saddam's possession -- his property. We can relate to that -- people treated as objects, as cogs, chattel, commodities. Saddam "the evildoer" is more than a simple tyrant. He violates unwritten codes of conduct towards private property, doesn't reinvest in his human capital. I mean, it's OK to lay off workers, raid their pension funds and 401K plans, strip them of health insurance, borrow against their childrens' future wealth, and scare the butt juice out of them with hysterical news stories, but we wouldn't go so far as gassing our own people or torturing them (unless they're enemy combatants). Saddam apparently hasn't been reading Fast Company or Business 2.0 in the past decade. "His own people" also conflates the many fragments of Iraqi society (ethnic groups, political factions) into one homogeneous, simple to understand group -- the people, "his people." The Iraqi people are like a lump of clay -- Saddam pounds them at will, and we will bomb them and tear a few pieces away as we grind them through our American cutting machines and hand them a new regime. When you can tell the people (our people) a simple story in terms of private ownership, you can really communicate something. All this rhetoric, by the way, plays midwife to a war being born, a war that will undoubtedly kill many more of "his own people"...in the name of saving them. (Google.com ) 20-Feb-2003