Re: Jail sentence for Ukrainian Trotskyist is an assault on free speech By Marv Gandall

This is all shameful nonsense! We, and I personally, know comrade Maksym 
Syrotiuk from our solidarity convoys to Ukraine in 2022 and met him 
twice. He is a very young (early 20s) student and has been an activist 
of Socialni Rukh. For the reactionary Ukrainian state apparatus 
everything socialist or communist ist "Russian" so there is no reason to 
believe them. This is like Chiang Kai-check (or Stalinists) accusing the 
Chinese Trotskyists as "agents of Japan" in the 1930s and 1940s. It 
should be not so difficult for democrats, not to speak about Marxists, 
to take a principled stance of solidarity with comrade Maksym Syrotiuk!

Am 27.08.2026 um 14:35 schrieb John Reimann via groups.io:
> There is a back and forth discussion between Pirani and me in the 
> comment section of his article. Pirani may have a valid point about 
> freedom of speech in Ukraine, but overall he portrays the view that is 
> all too common on the non-campist left that the "left" Putin 
> apologists and us are all part of one family and that we're basically 
> all on the same team. In his article Pirani writes "It beggars belief 
> that the Russian state would be stupid enough to fund the WSWS, or 
> that the WSWS would be stupid enough to accept that funding. In any 
> case, Syrotiuk would have known nothing about such arrangements."
>
> No, it doesn't beggar the imagination at all. Code Pink and PSL 
> receive large amounts of money from the Chinese Communist 
> Party-connected Roy Singham and the African Peoples Socialist Party 
> got money from Aleksandr Ionov. Those are just the above board cases. 
> An important part of Putin's strategy is to have agents and assets all 
> around the political spectrum, and given the position of WSWS, it 
> wouldn't surprise me in the least that the are Putin assets and even 
> paid agents in WSWS. Yes, it's true that WSWS "opposes" Putin, but 
> that is out of one side of their mouth. Then out of the other, the 
> cover up for him. For example, I went to a meeting of theirs several 
> years ago in which they denied the fact of the war crimes committed by 
> the Russian forces in Bucha. We see this sort of double speak from 
> neo-Nazis who say they don't like Hitler and then turn around and say 
> "but we just want a reexamination of the actual facts surrounding the 
> Holocaust."
>
> As for Syrotiuk himself: There was clothing with Russian insignia 
> allegedly found in the basement of the building where he lives. There 
> was no legal proof that that material belonged to him, but what 
> "beggars the imagination" is that it did not. Consider a hypothetical 
> situation in which such clothing with Nazi insignia had been found in 
> a similar location in a building during WW II. So, yes, I think 
> Syrotiuk was probably a conscious Russian agent.
>
> The fact that he and WSWS spout "left" sounding phrases means nothing. 
> Does anybody remember Borotba? They claimed to be communists and all 
> sorts of things. They had me fooled back in 2014. Then it turned out 
> they were Russian agents.
>
> Socialists need to stop this nonsense of letting Putin and his 
> defenders off the hook. I remember when Howie Hawkins debated Margaret 
> Kimberly. He refused to point out her complicity with fascists at the 
> AGMR conference. It was the same when Bill Fletcher debated Medea 
> Benjamin and said he considers her to be a comrade and failed to point 
> out her support for another dictatorship - the Iran 
> dictatorship. Without drawing these pictures, it's nearly impossible 
> for the uninitiated to understand what the difference is really all 
> about. It was the same - even worse, in fact - at the recent Porto 
> Alegre "anti fascist" conference that wasn't an anti-fascist 
> conference at all, as I've pointed out. (See: the International 
> "Anti-Fascist" conference that wasn't 
> <https://oaklandsocialist.com/2026/04/25/the-international-anti-fascist-conference-that-wasnt/>.)
>
> John Reimann
> 


-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group.
View/Reply Online (#43182): https://groups.io/g/marxmail/message/43182
Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/120955148/6024700
-=-=-
POSTING RULES & NOTES
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
#4 Do not exceed five posts a day.
-=-=-
Group Owner: [email protected]
Unsubscribe: https://groups.io/g/marxmail/leave/10173629/6024700/1441833971/xyzzy [[email protected]]
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-