The Ayn Rand World
"hibbsa" <[email protected]> Sun, 03 Feb 2013 14:43:02 -0000
| Newsgroups | gmane.science.physics.fabric-of-reality |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
In this brave new world why: - would anyone be willing to fight and die for their country, for a few hundred bucks a month? Where's the personal advantage right there for that person? - How would democracy work without an ethos of public service? Why should some elected official regard his duty as being to serve his constituency? Why not just the position to line his own pockets? - Why not be corrupt in general if it makes more money for a given individual in a given position? etc, etc, etc, why should anyone do anything that isn't in his personal immediate interest? For example, Ayn Rand herself took welfare later in her life. I've seen that defended as being exactly correct because her point was you act selfishly at all timeslly, so it's ok for her to take advantage of a system she totally disagreed with. So in other words, it wasn't an argument for her, that she shouldn't take the welfare because although there was an immedate benefit to her, ultimately she benefited more by not taking it, on the grounds if everyone did the same it would create a better world. So please no arguments based on the individual being swayed by some bigger more abstract benefit....giving his life for such a thing...in Ayn Rand terms.