using msDesc for rare books

Lou Burnard <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.text.tei.general
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Every now and then we hear tell of people using the TEI <msDesc> element 
to represent bibliographic information about things that are not 
strictly speaking manuscripts at all. I'm looking at a project which 
wants to encode very detailed information about specific copies of 
printed books (page layout, binding, ownership etc.) and I am wondering 
if there's a consensus out there about how to tweak <msDesc> for the 
purpose. Specifically, today I am wondering how people go about 
recording detailed notes about the printing of books, that is notes that 
say things like

"226 copies printed; 5 copies in-quarto, raisin on imperial Japan, with 
2 original engravings, numbered from I to V, plus an author's copy 
ex-series numbered 0; 20 copies in-quarto, raisin[1] on Hollande Van 
Helder, with 2 original engravings, numbered from VI to XXV; 200 copies 
in-octavo Jesus[1] on laid Alfa numbered from 1 to 200"

[This is my translation of the original, which reads "5 ex. in-quarto 
raisin sur Japon impérial avec deux gravures originales de Henri 
Laurens, numérotés de I à V ainsi qu'un ex. d'auteur hors série numéroté 
0 ; 20 ex. in-quarto raisin sur Hollande Van Gelder avec deux gravures 
originales de Henri Laurens, numérotés de VI à XXV ; 200 ex. in-octavo 
Jésus sur Alfa vergé numérotés de 1 à 200"]

I guess I could just wrap the whole thing in a <note type="copies"> but 
that seems a bit dull and doesn't capture the structure. Moreover, this 
is summary information about three (or possibly four) *groups* of 
copies, so it's not copy-specific in quite the same way as the physDesc 
of a msDesc would be.  Did someone say "frbr"?

[1] this is the name of the paper size, if you're wondering. Or so I 
learn from the internet "In olden times, a pattern or a letter drawn 
from the daily life of the paper makers and imprinted in the paper used 
to give it its name. People used to buy raisin paper (50 x 65cm) as it 
bore the imprint of a bunch of grapes, coquille paper (44 x 56cm), Jesus 
paper (56 x 76cm) with the imprint of Jesus' monogram – JHS –grand aigle 
paper (75 x 110cm), etc."
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.