for the telecon: belaboring the obvious
Steve Newcomb <srn-yd/[email protected]> Sun, 20 Nov 2011 21:32:54 -0500
| Newsgroups | gmane.text.xml.xtm.general |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
WG3 is an institution useful for the development and publication of international standards for the interchange and/or processing of subject-oriented information. WG3 has survived in an embryonic and turbulent arena for a pretty long time. It has somehow maintained a place for itself in the world. Maybe that longevity is useful. WG3's agenda cannot be inconsistent with the agendas of its international participants and their funders. Participation is the lifeblood of WG3. From WG3's perspective, participants are the sole source of WG3's energy. When participants agree that there is an opportunity for WG3 to develop a given standard, large or small, and when participants have pledged sufficient resources, then, with the consent of WG3, those participants should undertake the development, acting on behalf of WG3. One implication of this "allow a hundred flowers" approach is that WG3 would not claim any kind of unified architectural vision. It would neither claim nor require that all of its standards products conform to any sort of meta-standard. Another implication is that WG3 projects should not interfere with each other. In general, participants should not withhold their consent to WG3 undertaking any project on the basis of any existing standard or doctrine. WG3's engagement in a diverse program of work will make WG3's usefulness more obvious, and it is very likely to provide the most public benefit. Nobody can predict the future, and natural selection is not beneficial if there are not enough things to select from, and everything dies. So, for example, if a participant says he or she wants to develop an international standard for the interchange and/or processing of subject-oriented information, and if sufficient resources are available, then that standard is exactly what WG3 should develop, perhaps along with others. Steve Newcomb