Quirks with Garmin hardware

berend <[email protected]> Sun, 21 Dec 2025 13:58:06 +0000
Newsgroups dev.linux.lists.iwd
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Hi,

Some Garmin device firmware fails to clear the nonce in message 4 of
the handshake.  It's still the same nonce as in message 2.

If iwd is an AP, it fails the handshake, according to the spec.

I can make a quirk; by looking for a Garmin mac, or looking for an
identical nonce in messages 2 and 4.  Is it acceptable to add
workarounds for other hardware?


Berend
publickey - Berend De Schouwer - 0x128CD671.asc (application/pgp-keys, 3.1 KB)
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Comment: https://gopenpgp.org
Version: GopenPGP 2.8.2
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=9SXl
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 928 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: ProtonMail
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=T2go
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----