Re: [BUG] nouveau: drm_panic get_scanout_buffer() maps the BO from panic context (ioremap + sleeping locks)

On 15/08/2026 18:07, Marek Czernohous wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> In the cover letter of
> 
>    https://lore.kernel.org/nouveau/[email protected]/
> 
> I wrote that this was "a separate, pre-existing problem which I have
> not yet reported; I will do so on its own".  This is that report.  It
> is a new thread rather than a follow-up there, because the subsystem
> and the maintainers are different ones and that series has since been
> superseded.
> 
> nouveau's drm_panic scanout callback establishes a CPU mapping while
> the machine is already panicking.  nv50_wndw_get_scanout_buffer()
> calls nouveau_bo_map(), which takes two sleeping locks and then, for
> a VRAM buffer, calls ioremap().  On x86 that ends in
> __get_vm_area_node(), which BUG_ON()s when it is entered from hard
> IRQ or NMI context.
> 
> I hit this once, on 2026-06-02, on an Apple Macmini3,1 (MCP79 /
> GeForce 9400M, NVAC, nv50/Tesla, 256 MB VRAM) running 7.0.10-p1.
> The panic screen was never drawn; instead the panic handler took a
> second oops inside panic().
> 
> I am reporting this rather than sending a patch, because the two
> panic-safe helpers that exist in-tree (ttm_bo_kmap_try_from_panic()
> and drm_scanout_buffer.pages) do not cover an iomem scanout buffer,
> and I do not want to pick the design direction for someone else's
> driver.

Yes the nouveau drm panic implementation is not perfect. The framebuffer 
is not accessible from the CPU, so the only way to display something is 
to ioremap it, and currently that is not possible safely in a panic context.
I still think that it works well enough, and that it's still better than 
a frozen display.

Regarding the design direction, I think it would be nice to have 
something similar to kmap_local_page() for iomem.
I will review and help with testing any patch that can improve the 
current situation.

Thanks and best regards,

-- 

Jocelyn
> 
> Below I try to keep three things strictly apart: what is verified in
> current mainline source, what was observed exactly once, and what is
> speculation.
> 
> Verified against mainline c21bb4193868 ("Merge tag ..." of
> 2026-08-04); the relevant files are byte-identical in netdev/main
> (9006c116dd11, 2026-08-13).
> 
> 1. The contract
> ---------------
> 
> drm_panic calls ->get_scanout_buffer() from draw_panic_plane()
> (drivers/gpu/drm/drm_panic.c:930), inside drm_panic_trylock()
> (:927), which is a raw_spin_trylock_irqsave() on
> dev->mode_config.panic_lock (include/drm/drm_panic.h:133).  By that
> time vpanic() has already run local_irq_disable() and
> preempt_disable_notrace() (kernel/panic.c:600,601) and stopped the
> other CPUs via panic_other_cpus_shutdown() (:551, called at :673),
> all before kmsg_dump_desc(KMSG_DUMP_PANIC, buf) at :685.
> 
> The restrictions are written down:
> 
>    drm_panic.c:63-67
>      "It is a panic handler, so it can't take lock, allocate memory,
>       run tasks/irq, or attempt to sleep."
> 
>    include/drm/drm_modeset_helper_vtables.h:1443-1462, on
>    ->get_scanout_buffer:
>      "It is called from a panic callback, and must follow its
>       restrictions. Please look the documentation at
>       drm_panic_trylock() for an in-depth discussions of what's safe
>       and what is not allowed."
> 
>    include/drm/drm_panic.h:105-125, on drm_panic_trylock():
>      "... without taking any further locks (which would be impossible
>       in panic context anyway)"
> 
> 2. What nouveau does
> --------------------
> 
> drivers/gpu/drm/nouveau/dispnv50/wndw.c:651,
> nv50_wndw_get_scanout_buffer(), line 671:
> 
> 	if (nouveau_bo_map(nvbo)) {
> 
> That single call does the following, in order.
> 
> (a) Always: nouveau_bo.c:672 takes
>      ttm_bo_reserve(&nvbo->bo, false, false, NULL).  With
>      no_wait = false this resolves to dma_resv_lock(), i.e.
>      ww_mutex_lock() (include/drm/ttm/ttm_bo.h:287-306), a sleeping
>      lock, taken under a raw spinlock with interrupts off.
> 
>      It returned on 2026-06-02 only because the reservation was
>      uncontended and the ww_mutex fastpath is atomic.  If it is held,
>      the owner is either a task that will never be scheduled again or
>      a CPU that smp_send_stop() has already halted, so the panic path
>      would hang instead of dying.  This violation is invisible in the
>      trace; CONFIG_DEBUG_ATOMIC_SLEEP or lockdep would show it.
> 
> (b) Conditionally: ttm_bo_kmap() calls ttm_mem_io_reserve()
>      (ttm/ttm_bo_util.c:439), which returns early only if
>      reg->bus.offset or reg->bus.addr is already set
>      (ttm_bo_util.c:49-60).  Otherwise it enters
>      nouveau_ttm_io_mem_reserve() (nouveau_bo.c:1254), which takes
>      mutex_lock(&drm->ttm.io_reserve_mutex) (:1262) and, for the NV50
>      memory class (which is what NVAC uses, nvkm/subdev/mmu/mcp77.c),
>      calls nvif_object_map_handle() (:1324) to obtain a BAR1 window.
>      That path does kzalloc(..., GFP_KERNEL) (nvif/object.c:158) and
>      takes mutex_lock(&vmm->mutex.vmm) in nvkm_vmm_get()
>      (nvkm/subdev/mmu/vmm.c:1864).  On -ENOSPC it walks
>      drm->ttm.io_reserve_lru and tears down someone else's mapping
>      via drm_vma_node_unmap() (nouveau_bo.c:1342-1355), which on a
>      256 MB part with a small BAR1 is not a theoretical branch.
> 
>      I cannot tell from the trace whether this branch was taken on
>      2026-06-02; there is no nouveau_ttm_io_mem_reserve frame, but it
>      may have been inlined.  I list it as a code-analysis finding,
>      not as an observation.
> 
> (c) Always, for a VRAM buffer: ttm_bo_kmap() sets map->virtual =
>      NULL unconditionally (ttm_bo_util.c:432), so an existing mapping
>      is never reused, and then takes the is_iomem branch
>      (ttm_bo_util.c:442-447) into ttm_bo_ioremap() (:314-338).  The
>      premapped shortcut at :321-323 requires mem->bus.addr, and
>      nouveau never sets bus.addr anywhere: the only assignment in the
>      driver sets it back to NULL (nouveau_bo.c:1354).  So a real
>      ioremap_wc()/ioremap() happens (:329, :335), which on x86 goes
>      __ioremap_caller() (arch/x86/mm/ioremap.c:184) ->
>      get_vm_area_caller() (:292) -> __get_vm_area_node()
>      (mm/vmalloc.c:3197).
> 
>      __get_vm_area_node() starts with, in c21bb4193868 at
>      mm/vmalloc.c:3206:
> 
> 	BUG_ON(in_nmi() || in_hardirq());
> 
>      and then does kzalloc_node() (:3215) and alloc_vmap_area()
>      (:3226) with GFP_KERNEL.
> 
> The scanout buffer really is in VRAM and really is iomem:
> nv50_wndw_prepare_fb() pins it with
> nouveau_bo_pin(nvbo, NOUVEAU_GEM_DOMAIN_VRAM, true) (wndw.c:553-556)
> and never maps it; nv50_wndw_cleanup_fb() never unmaps.
> nouveau_ttm_io_mem_reserve() sets bus.is_iomem = true for
> TTM_PL_VRAM (nouveau_bo.c:1285-1288).  nvbo->kmap is not populated
> elsewhere for a framebuffer either: nouveau_bo_map() is otherwise
> only used for the dispnv04 cursor, disp->sync, push buffers and
> fence BOs, while GEM and fbdev buffers go through
> drm_gem_ttm_vmap()/ttm_bo_vmap(), which uses its own iosys_map and
> never touches bo->kmap.  So on nv50+ the panic callback maps the
> framebuffer for the first time, every time.
> 
> Avoiding the iomem branch would not help: ttm_bo_kmap_ttm()
> (ttm_bo_util.c:340-380) calls ttm_bo_populate() and then vmap()
> (:376) for anything larger than a single cached page, and
> nouveau_bo_map() asks for PFN_UP(bo.base.size) pages
> (nouveau_bo.c:676).  vmap() goes through the same
> get_vm_area_caller() (mm/vmalloc.c:3560).
> 
> 3. Version note on the BUG_ON, so nobody trips over the line number
> -------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> The crash kernel printed "kernel BUG at mm/vmalloc.c:3212".  In the
> v7.0 tree that line is literally
> 
> 	BUG_ON(in_interrupt());
> 
> (verified against v7.0-rc7, function head at :3203).  Commit
> 04aa71da5f35 ("mm/vmalloc: do not trigger BUG() on BH disabled
> context", author date 2026-05-15, Cc: stable) narrowed it to
> BUG_ON(in_nmi() || in_hardirq()), which is mm/vmalloc.c:3206 today.
> That commit reached mainline on 2026-05-26 via merge d60ec36cab338,
> while 7.0.10 was released on 2026-05-23, so the crash ran against
> the old form.  Both line numbers are correct, each only for its own
> tree.
> 
> Practical consequence, stated deliberately narrowly: the observed
> case, panic entered from a hard IRQ, still hits the BUG_ON on
> current mainline.  A panic from process context does not, but the
> same path still ioremaps, still allocates with GFP_KERNEL and still
> takes two sleeping locks under a raw spinlock with interrupts
> disabled.  The relaxation makes the failure quieter, not correct.
> I am not claiming an unconditional BUG on mainline.
> 
> 4. What was actually observed (one occurrence)
> ----------------------------------------------
> 
> Kernel 7.0.10-p1-gentoo-dist, PREEMPT(lazy), CONFIG_DRM_PANIC=y,
> labwc/Wayland, Apple Inc. Macmini3,1/Mac-F22C86C8.
> Tainted: G S D OE.
> 
> The initiating oops was my own fault and is not part of this report:
> an out-of-tree patch of mine called nvkm_chan_error(chan, true) on a
> g84_chan, which has no .preempt, giving a NULL function pointer in
> the FIFO CACHE_ERROR handler.  That bug is fixed.  An oops in
> interrupt context is fatal by design, so panic() was entered
> legitimately; what this report is about is what happened next.
> 
> Relevant part of the netconsole capture (definite frames only, "? "
> entries dropped):
> 
>    nouveau 0000:02:00.0: fifo: CACHE_ERROR - ch 2 [labwc[3950]]
>      subc 3 mthd 0f00 data 0000007b
>    BUG: kernel NULL pointer dereference, address: 0000000000000000
>    Oops: Oops: 0010 [#1] SMP PTI
>    RIP: 0010:0x0
>    ...
>    Kernel panic - not syncing: Fatal exception in interrupt
> 
>    kernel BUG at mm/vmalloc.c:3212!
>    Oops: invalid opcode: 0000 [#2] SMP PTI
>    CPU: 0 UID: 290 PID: 6267 Comm: apps.plugin Tainted: G S    D
>      OE       7.0.10-p1-gentoo-dist #1 PREEMPT(lazy)
>    Hardware name: Apple Inc. Macmini3,1/Mac-F22C86C8
>    RIP: 0010:__get_vm_area_node+0x15a/0x160
>    Call Trace:
>     <IRQ>
>     get_vm_area_caller+0x3e/0x60
>     __ioremap_caller+0x235/0x340
>     ttm_bo_kmap+0x2b2/0x310 [ttm]
>     nouveau_bo_map+0x4b/0xa0 [nouveau]
>     nv50_wndw_get_scanout_buffer+0x9b/0x1b0 [nouveau]
>     draw_panic_plane+0x9e/0x170
>     kmsg_dump_desc+0x6c/0xa0
>     vpanic+0x301/0x450
>     panic+0x6b/0x70
>     oops_end.cold+0xc/0x1d
>     page_fault_oops+0x174/0x180
>     exc_page_fault+0x82/0x1d0
>     asm_exc_page_fault+0x26/0x30
> 
> The machine was then rebooted by the nv_tco watchdog after roughly
> 30 seconds.
> 
> Caveats that belong with this trace:
> 
>   - netconsole delivered over UDP from two CPUs.  Oops #1 and oops #2
>     arrived interleaved line by line, and all lines of the panic
>     burst carry the same kernel timestamp [39189.170158].  The line
>     contents are unmodified; the ordering above is reconstructed by
>     hand and cannot be read off the file.
>   - There is one "Call Trace:" and one "Modules linked in:" in the
>     captured window for both oopses.  Attributing the
>     CPU/UID/PID/Comm line with [D]=DIE to oops #2 is an inference,
>     not a label in the log.
>   - The kernel was [O]/[E] tainted because nouveau was built
>     out-of-tree with local patches.  None of those patches touch
>     dispnv50/wndw.c, nouveau_bo.c or ttm; the drm_panic path was
>     unmodified mainline.
>   - This is one occurrence on one machine on an old kernel.  It is
>     not a recipe.  The code analysis in sections 1 to 3 is what
>     carries this report; the trace only shows that the path is
>     reached in practice.
> 
> That the path is still armed on this box today is easy to check:
> the currently running 7.1.8 kernel has CONFIG_DRM_PANIC=y and logs
> "[drm] Registered 2 planes with drm panic" at every boot, and
> /proc/vmallocinfo currently lists two live mappings
> 
>    ... ttm_bo_kmap+0x2b2/0x310 [ttm] phys=0x00000000c0000000 ioremap
> 
> with 0xc0000000-0xcfffffff being nouveau's BAR1 in /proc/iomem and
> write-combining in pat_memtype_list.  Same caller offset as in the
> crash trace.
> 
> 5. Reproducing it
> -----------------
> 
> I have not reproduced it deliberately.  Two notes for whoever wants
> to:
> 
>   - lkdtm has PANIC_IN_HARDIRQ (drivers/misc/lkdtm/bugs.c), which
>     panics from an HRTIMER_MODE_REL_HARD callback, i.e. exactly the
>     context in question, and it already exists in v7.0.  That should
>     be the deterministic reproducer on any drm_panic-enabled driver.
>     CONFIG_LKDTM is not built in my kernel, so I have not run it.
>   - CONFIG_DRM_PANIC_DEBUG is not a reproducer for this.  Its
>     debugfs write handler calls draw_panic_plane() from an ordinary
>     write(2), where in_hardirq()/in_nmi()/in_interrupt() are all
>     false, so the BUG_ON does not fire.  drm_panic.c:965-968 says so
>     itself: "This is currently unsafe. ... TODO: It would be better
>     to emulate an NMI context."  With CONFIG_DEBUG_ATOMIC_SLEEP it
>     should still catch violation (a) as a sleeping-in-atomic splat.
> 
> 6. Scope
> --------
> 
> nv50_wndw_get_scanout_buffer() is the only ->get_scanout_buffer
> implementation in the whole driver (git grep over
> drivers/gpu/drm/nouveau gives dispnv50/wndw.c:596,651,716 only).  It
> hangs off nv50_wndw_primary_helper (wndw.c:716), bound to primary
> planes at wndw.c:892.  dispnv50 covers Tesla through Blackwell, so
> every nouveau generation that has drm_panic at all is affected;
> dispnv04 has no implementation and is therefore unaffected.  NVAC is
> not a special case, only the oldest one.
> 
> Introduced by 1d26c846f3ff ("drm/nouveau: Add drm_panic support for
> nv50+", Jocelyn Falempe, 2024-10-22), first released in v6.13; the
> nouveau_bo_map() call is in that commit already, so this is not a
> later regression.  The function body is byte-identical between
> 1d26c846f3ff and c21bb4193868 (md5 of the extracted body
> 1157ba4019a2e1c8a12494ab81c68342); wndw.c itself has been touched
> since, but not this function.
> 
> As far as I can see this has not been reported for nouveau before.
> lore.kernel.org is blocked from this machine, so I searched the
> mail-archive.com mirror of dri-devel instead: "get_scanout_buffer"
> returns the original nv50+ drm_panic series, two build-robot reports
> against wndw.c, and my own cover letter quoted above; "drm_panic
> ioremap" returns only the ttm_bo_kmap_try_from_panic() series.  If
> somebody with working lore access finds a duplicate, please point me
> at it.
> 
> 7. Why the existing panic-safe helpers do not simply fix it
> -----------------------------------------------------------
> 
> ttm_bo_kmap_try_from_panic() (ttm/ttm_bo_util.c:396-406, added by
> 718370ff2832, "drm/ttm: Add ttm_bo_kmap_try_from_panic()") returns
> NULL as soon as bo->resource->bus.is_iomem is set (:400-401), which
> is precisely the nouveau VRAM scanout case.  Its own commit message
> says: "Unfortunately there is no way to do the same with ioremap,
> so it only supports the kmap case."  Its only in-tree user is xe
> (xe/display/xe_panic.c:68).
> 
> drm_scanout_buffer.pages (include/drm/drm_panic.h:42-50) needs a
> struct page array, which a BAR aperture does not have.  Its
> documentation also notes that the array "shouldn't be allocated
> from the get_scanoutbuffer() callback".
> 
> So the general rule these two encode is not "call helper X" but "do
> not establish a mapping and do not take a lock inside the panic
> handler".  Drivers that get this right pre-establish the mapping:
> 
>   - ast: devm_ioremap_wc of the VRAM BAR at probe (ast_mm.c:89),
>     callback just uses ast->vram + offset (ast_mode.c:625-639).
>   - mgag200: same shape (mgag200_drv.c:152,156;
>     mgag200_mode.c:549-564).
>   - drm_sysfb (simpledrm, vesadrm): passes through sysfb->fb_addr
>     (drm_sysfb_modeset.c:408-421).
>   - xe: keeps the LMEM BAR mapped via devm_ioremap_wc
>     (xe_vram.c:59, :245) and computes vram->mapping + res.start in
>     set_pixel, using ttm_bo_kmap_try_from_panic() only for the
>     system-memory case (xe_panic.c:53-70); non CPU-visible VRAM is
>     rejected up front.
>   - i915: uses an existing obj->mm.mapping or a page list, with the
>     per-fb intel_panic allocated at fb creation (intel_fb.c:2223).
>   - virtio-gpu: passes the existing shmem->pages list
>     (virtgpu_plane.c:508-537).
>   - bochs, hyperv and the drm_fb_dma users follow the same pattern.
> 
> amdgpu is worth mentioning because it is *not* clean either, and I
> would rather say so than present nouveau as a unique slip: its
> indirect-MMIO set_pixel (amdgpu_display.c:1843-1862) is gated on
> AMDGPU_GEM_CREATE_NO_CPU_ACCESS (:1893), and the fallthrough at
> :1907-1908 calls ttm_bo_kmap() from the panic handler just like
> nouveau.  What saves it in practice is that
> amdgpu_ttm_io_mem_reserve() prefills mem->bus.addr from the
> permanently ioremapped visible aperture adev->mman.aper_base_kaddr
> (amdgpu_ttm.c:655-658, mapping created at :2134), so
> ttm_bo_ioremap() takes the premapped branch and no mapping is
> created during panic.  It also guards with
> "if (!abo->kmap.virtual && ...)", which nouveau does not have.
> This looks like a pattern worth auditing across drm_panic providers
> rather than a single nouveau bug.
> 
> 8. What I found when I looked for a fix
> ---------------------------------------
> 
> I went looking for the obvious fix and did not find one that is
> obviously right, which is the main reason this is a report and not a
> patch.  What follows is reconnaissance, not a proposal: two shapes I
> looked at and the traps I ran into, in case it saves someone the
> same walk.  You know this code better than I do, and there may well
> be a third shape I did not see.
> 
> (A) Establish the mapping outside panic context and only consume it
>      inside.  drm_panic.h:115-120 blesses that location: anything set
>      up by prepare_fb and torn down by cleanup_fb is safe to access,
>      because the framebuffer is pinned.  nv50_wndw_prepare_fb()
>      already pins and would be the natural place to map.
> 
>      What made me stop: it permanently occupies BAR1 aperture plus
>      kernel VA for every scanout FB, and takes the buffer out of the
>      io_reserve_lru that nouveau uses to resolve BAR1 pressure.
>      prepare_fb and cleanup_fb are shared between nv50_wndw_helper
>      and nv50_wndw_primary_helper while get_scanout_buffer only
>      exists on the primary, so cursor and overlay BOs would be mapped
>      too unless that is restricted.  And nvbo->kmap is a single
>      non-refcounted field, so a second ttm_bo_kmap() overwrites and
>      leaks the previous mapping.  On a 256 MB part those are not
>      theoretical costs, but I cannot judge what they are worth on a
>      modern card.
> 
> (B) An amdgpu-style set_pixel with no CPU mapping of the FB at all.
>      nouveau has a sliding BAR0 window on Tesla:
>      nv50_instmem_set_bar0_window_addr() writes addr >> 16 to
>      0x001700 (nvkm/subdev/instmem/nv50.c:397-401), data then
>      reachable at 0x700000 + (addr & 0xfffff) (nv50.c:56-73), on
>      device->pri, which is ioremapped once at probe
>      (nvkm/engine/device/base.c:3173).  drm_panic does not require a
>      mapping when set_pixel is provided (drm_panic.c:936).
> 
>      What made me stop: nv50_instobj_wr32_slow() cannot be reused
>      because it takes spin_lock_irqsave(&imem->base.lock), which a
>      stopped CPU may hold, so the window writes would have to be
>      open-coded.  nvkm_vram_addr() returns ~0ULL for non-contiguous
>      VRAM (nvkm/subdev/fb/ram.c:65-71), so contiguity has to be
>      checked rather than assumed, even though prepare_fb pins with
>      contig = true.  And this is a Tesla-specific mechanism, so it
>      says nothing about Fermi and later.
> 
> One thing that is not a matter of taste: nouveau has no persistent
> BAR1 mapping to reuse today.  git grep ioremap over
> drivers/gpu/drm/nouveau yields only BAR0/PRI, the BAR2/PRAMIN
> windows in instmem, and dispnv04/hw.c.  nouveau_ttm.c sets up MTRR
> and a WC memtype over the BAR1 range, which is not a mapping.  So
> either shape means new infrastructure.
> 
> Two things I would ask rather than assert:
> 
>   - Is losing the panic screen on nv50+ an acceptable interim state?
>     Not mapping at all and returning an error would be a small,
>     backportable change, and the screen is lost today anyway, only
>     more loudly.  But that trades a feature for a crash fix and I do
>     not know how you weigh that.
> 
>   - Should whatever lands here also cover violations (a) and (b)?
>     Replacing only the ioremap leaves the sleeping lock and the
>     GFP_KERNEL allocation in place, and those are the ones that would
>     hang rather than die.
> 
> Happy to test patches on the NVAC box, and to run lkdtm
> PANIC_IN_HARDIRQ there if a kernel with CONFIG_LKDTM is wanted.
> 
> Regards,
> Marek
> 
> ---
> Note on tooling: this analysis was AI-assisted.  I used Claude
> (claude-opus-5) as an analysis assistant for reading the code paths
> and cross-checking line numbers and commit history.  All numbers,
> traces and measurements in this mail come from the machine described
> above and from the mainline tree at c21bb4193868; I reviewed every
> claim myself and I am responsible for any error in it.  No
> Signed-off-by is claimed by the tool.
>