Re: [PATCH] can: kvaser_pciefd: fix use-after-free in bec poll timer

Hi Marc,

Yes. The driver has three timer_delete() call sites, all for
bec_poll_timer.

The calls in kvaser_pciefd_bus_on() and kvaser_pciefd_stop() are runtime
cancellations: the CAN device stays alive after both, and the timer must
stay rearmable for the next open/bus-on cycle, since the interrupt
handler arms it from handle_error_packet(), handle_status_resp() and
handle_status_packet().  Converting either one to timer_shutdown_sync()
would make those later mod_timer() calls no-ops.  The stop() flush-timeout
path, which skips its timer_delete() entirely, is also covered: the device
is still alive there, and remove() still shuts the timer down
unconditionally.

kvaser_pciefd_remove() is different: its timer_delete() is followed by
free_irq() and then by the final free_candev(), while the interrupt
handler can still rearm the timer.  That is the call converted by this
patch, which also adds timer_shutdown_sync() to
kvaser_pciefd_teardown_can_ctrls(), the probe-error path that frees the
CAN devices after free_irq().

Thanks,
Fan

> On Aug 18, 2026, at 20:00, Marc Kleine-Budde <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> On 18.08.2026 06:38:32, Fan Wu wrote:
>> The bec poll timer is rearmed from the interrupt handler, so the
>> timer_delete() call in kvaser_pciefd_remove() neither waits for a
> 
> There are more timer_delete() in the code, have you had a look at them,
> too?
> 
> regards,
> Marc