Re: [mlmmj] What do you do with Gmail accounts?

Hello Konstantin,

Am 05.03.24 um 17:04 schrieb Konstantin Ryabitsev:

>> Reply-To-munging seems to be the only way to give Gmail-users the
>> possibility to answer direct to the list. But is is impossible to be done in
>> Mlmmj.
>>
>> What to do?
> 
> If you rewrite headers such as Reply-To, this will almost certainly invalidate
> the DKIM signature of the original message if you also keep the original
> "From:" header. If you want to modify any signed headers, you *must* rewrite
> the From: address.
> 
> There are only two possible solutions when it comes to mailing lists these
> days:
> 
> 1. Don't touch any headers, only add List-* headers (e.g. List-ID)
> 2. If you do change any headers, you *must* also rewrite the original From:
>     header (e.g. by moving it to X-Original-From:), because otherwise you will
>     violate DKIM/DMARC policies of the sender's domain

Ok. I will choose (1). The poor guys at Gmail have to live with it that 
they cannot hit 'Reply' to answer to the list. Instead they have to 
choose 'Reply to all' with which Gmail would send:

To: authors_email@domain
CC: list@listserver

Then they have to delete 'authors_email@domain' from 'To:' and move 
'list@listserver' to 'To:'.

Their bad luck to be with this provider.

---

When I add this header:

'Mail-Reply-To:  list@listserver'

Thunderbird and Claws Mail and a lot of other MUAs reply to 
'list@listserver' when the user hits <Ctrl-R>.

And DKIM is not broken.

Thank you all!

Alles Gute

Christof Thalhofer

-- 
Dies ist keine Signatur