Re: What it the correct way to add photos to a gedcom??

So after reading the bits and pieces of the 5.5 grammer I see:

MULTIMEDIA_LINK: =

   [          /* embedded form*/
   n  OBJE @<XREF:OBJE>@  {1:1}
   |          /* linked form*/
   n  OBJE           {1:1}
     +1 FORM <MULTIMEDIA_FORMAT>  {1:1}
     +1 TITL <DESCRIPTIVE_TITLE>  {0:1}
     +1 FILE <MULTIMEDIA_FILE_REFERENCE>  {1:1}
     +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
   ]

and it appears that <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>> is allow under an INDI record:

INDIVIDUAL_RECORD: =

n @<XREF:INDI>@  INDI {1:1}
     +1 RESN <RESTRICTION_NOTICE>  {0:1}
     +1 <<PERSONAL_NAME_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
     +1 SEX <SEX_VALUE>   {0:1}
     +1 <<INDIVIDUAL_EVENT_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<INDIVIDUAL_ATTRIBUTE_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<LDS_INDIVIDUAL_ORDINANCE>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<CHILD_TO_FAMILY_LINK>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<SPOUSE_TO_FAMILY_LINK>>  {0:M}
     +1 SUBM @<XREF:SUBM>@  {0:M}
     +1 <<ASSOCIATION_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
     +1 ALIA @<XREF:INDI>@  {0:M}
     +1 ANCI @<XREF:SUBM>@  {0:M}
     +1 DESI @<XREF:SUBM>@  {0:M}
     +1 <<SOURCE_CITATION>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<MULTIMEDIA_LINK>>  {0:M}
     +1 <<NOTE_STRUCTURE>>  {0:M}
     +1 RFN <PERMANENT_RECORD_FILE_NUMBER>  {0:1}
     +1 AFN <ANCESTRAL_FILE_NUMBER>  {0:1}
     +1 REFN <USER_REFERENCE_NUMBER>  {0:M}
       +2 TYPE <USER_REFERENCE_TYPE>  {0:1}
     +1 RIN <AUTOMATED_RECORD_ID>  {0:1}
     +1 <<CHANGE_DATE>>  {0:1}

So this looks like a bug in Gedcom Vers 1.16 that I downloaded from CPAN 
last night.

Thoughts?

-Steve

On 12/23/2012 5:32 PM, Stephen Woodbridge wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> I want to automate adding photos to my gedcom file.
>
> I created a trivial file in PAF 5.2.18.0 and added a photo and got the
> following file:
>
> 0 HEAD
> 1 SOUR PAF
> 2 NAME Personal Ancestral File
> 2 VERS 5.2.18.0
> 2 CORP The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
> 3 ADDR 50 East North Temple Street
> 4 CONT Salt Lake City, UT 84150
> 4 CONT USA
> 1 DEST PAF
> 1 DATE 23 Dec 2012
> 2 TIME 17:12:31
> 1 FILE test.ged
> 1 GEDC
> 2 VERS 5.5
> 2 FORM LINEAGE-LINKED
> 1 CHAR UTF-8
> 1 LANG English
> 1 SUBM @SUB1@
> 0 @SUB1@ SUBM
> 1 NAME Stephen Woodbridge
> 0 @I1@ INDI
> 1 NAME Stephen /Woodbridge/
> 2 SURN Woodbridge
> 2 GIVN Stephen
> 1 SEX M
> 1 _UID 51190DB94CBF254F8654B3F06C2E42343CF0
> 1 CHAN
> 2 DATE 23 Dec 2012
> 3 TIME 17:11:18
> 1 OBJE
> 2 FORM jpg
> 2 FILE Misc photos\Steve-large.jpg
> 2 TITL This is a caption.
> 2 NOTE Bla bla bla.
> 2 _SCBK Y
> 2 _PRIM Y
> 2 _TYPE PHOTO
> 2 _SSHOW Y
> 0 TRLR
>
> I tried to create the same in Gedcom.pm but I get these warnings:
>
> FORM is not a sub-item of OBJE
> FILE is not a sub-item of OBJE
> TITL is not a sub-item of OBJE
> *:0: FILE is not a sub-item of OBJE
> *:0: TITL is not a sub-item of OBJE
> *:0: FORM is not a sub-item of OBJE
>
> The output file appears to be created as requested, but I'm not sure why
> I'm getting these warnings.
>
> I also noticed that PAF adds a lot of _TAG items to the file. Is this
> part of the standard for application specific tags?
>
> Thanks,
>    -Steve